Roofing discussions and local services.
Roofing Brands & Products
Explore comparisons, reviews, installation feedback, and experiences related to leading roofing brands, product lines, and accessories for residential roofing.
Forums in this category
Discussions
How much waste allowance is reasonable on an OC shingle quote?
How do you compare Owens Corning shingle quantities when bids use different waste allowances? Roof area alone may not tell the whole story if the layout has several…
hypothetical scenario: your roofer skips the underlayment step - what would you do?
Okay, so imagine this... you're getting your roof redone, and you specifically chose CertainTeed's Integrity Roof System because you heard good things. But then, um, you notice the…
Comparing Decra quotes when the roof details are complicated
I’m trying to compare Decra quotes for a roof of roughly 28 squares with several different details: about a 7/12 main roof, two valleys, one chimney, two skylights,…
Tamko Heritage vs Atlas Pinnacle Pristine in a damp, windy climate
I’m comparing **Tamko Heritage** and **Atlas Pinnacle Pristine** for an asphalt-shingle replacement, and I’m trying not to choose based only on color or brand reputation. The house is…
favorite Tamko shingle colors - what's yours?
Been looking at Tamko shingles lately, and man, picking a color is harder than I thought. I kinda lean towards the rustic black, but my wife thinks weathered…
Timberline HDZ vs AS II for a hail-prone rental roof
I’m evaluating GAF Timberline HDZ versus Timberline AS II for a rental property and would appreciate input on the full cost rather than shingle price alone. The building…
When do exposed fasteners make sense over concealed panels?
For a straightforward agricultural or utility roof, exposed-fastener panels can reduce material cost and simplify installation. The trade-off gets less favorable as the roof becomes lower-pitched, more weather-exposed,…
Does Changing Roofing Material Make Existing Flashing and Vents a False Saving?
I’m comparing reroofing bids for a property with an approximately 15-year-old asphalt shingle roof. One proposal keeps asphalt shingles, while another changes to a metal roofing system. The…
Factory-Finished Reflective Cap Sheet or Renewable Field Coating?
I’m comparing two ways to improve a low-slope roof’s reflectivity: a factory-finished reflective cap sheet or a conventional cap sheet renewed later with a field-applied reflective coating. IKO…
How much extra is reasonable for Landmark Pro?
I’m comparing two CertainTeed roof quotes and want to judge the Landmark Pro upgrade by the whole system, not just the shingle name. The roof has valleys and…