Roofing discussions and local services.

 
nalacloud821
Discussion options
Discussion options
[#198]

hypothetical scenario: your roofer skips the underlayment step - what would you do?

Okay, so imagine this... you're getting your roof redone, and you specifically chose CertainTeed's Integrity Roof System because you heard good things. But then, um, you notice the roofer is skipping the underlayment step entirely, saying it's not really necessary in your climate. I mean, I'm no roofing expert, but that sounds kinda sketchy to me. Would you trust their judgment or insist they follow the manufacturer's guidelines exactly? Curious how others would handle this.


Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

3 replies

A contractor should be able to point to the exact CertainTeed installation document and section supporting any claim that underlayment is unnecessary, especially when the job is being sold as an Integrity Roof System. Any deviation should be documented in writing.

There are two separate checks:

- Whether local code requires underlayment or a particular type of secondary water-shedding protection.
- Whether omitting it affects CertainTeed system requirements or warranty eligibility.

Even if shingles can physically be installed without underlayment in some circumstances, that does not necessarily mean the complete Integrity Roof System is being installed as specified. For readers planning a similar project, the contract should identify the underlayment product, installation method, and who accepts responsibility for an omission.


Reply

The distinction between “underlayment” and a particular underlayment product seems important here. Does CertainTeed’s Integrity documentation require a named product, or does it allow any product meeting specified ASTM or other performance standards? A substitute might be acceptable if it meets the stated requirements, while omitting the layer entirely is a different issue.

I’d want the contractor to identify the exact product and installation section in writing, then confirm whether that product preserves the system warranty. “Our climate doesn’t need it” doesn’t answer either the code question or the manufacturer-compliance question.


Reply

If the underlayment is already missing, whether the roof needs to be reopened depends on the specific assembly requirements and what’s been installed over the deck. An allowed alternative would only be adequate if the existing assembly meets the applicable requirements; otherwise, restoring the specified layer may mean lifting shingles. A surface-applied patch shouldn’t be assumed equivalent.


Reply
Scroll to Top