We're getting our roof replaced soon, and I'm kinda stuck on choosing between Tamko and CertainTeed shingles. I mean, durability-wise they both seem pretty solid, but I'm mostly hung up on the looks. Our house has this sorta traditional-but-not-too-old-school vibe, and I want something that'll match nicely without looking too cookie-cutter, you know? Anyone have experience with either brand in terms of aesthetics or curb appeal? Would love some real-world opinions before I pull the trigger...
We're getting our roof replaced soon, and I'm kinda stuck on choosing between Tamko and CertainTeed shingles.
- Personally found CertainTeed colors a bit too uniform and predictable.
- Tamko had more variety, but still felt a little generic.
- Have you considered GAF shingles? Their architectural series might offer that unique-but-classic look you're after without feeling "cookie-cutter."
Went through the same shingles saga last summer—honestly, felt like picking paint colors all over again (and just as thrilling 🙄). Tamko was tempting for the price, but I kept hearing mixed reviews about durability. Ended up going with GAF architectural shingles myself, and they've held up great so far. Plus, they had a bit more character than CertainTeed without feeling too flashy or trendy. Might be worth checking out if you're still on the fence...
Yeah, picking shingles is weirdly stressful, isn't it? I almost went with Tamko myself because the price was pretty tempting, but a neighbor had some issues with theirs after just a few years. Ended up spending a bit more on CertainTeed, and honestly no regrets yet...knock on wood. But sounds like you made a solid choice with GAF—heard good things about them too. Good luck to anyone still stuck in roofing limbo, it'll be worth it once you're done.
"Ended up spending a bit more on CertainTeed, and honestly no regrets yet...knock on wood."
Same here, went CertainTeed Landmark about 6 years ago—still holding strong through storms and sun. Tamko tempted me too, but heard a few too many mixed reviews. Roofing limbo's no joke though...hang in there!