Those old Tamko shingles are like the cockroaches of the roofing world—ugly, stubborn, and somehow still hanging on after everything else has bit the dust. I’ve patched up plenty of “fancy” roofs that were barely five years old, but my neighbor’s barn still has the original Tamkos from the Reagan era. Sure, they look like they’ve been chewed up and spit out, but not a drip inside. I guess there’s something about starting out in a chicken coop that teaches you how to keep the rain out, no matter what. Midwest weather doesn’t mess around, and neither do those old-school shingles.
I’ve patched up plenty of “fancy” roofs that were barely five years old, but my neighbor’s barn still has the original Tamkos from the Reagan era.
Funny how that works. I’ve torn off a lot of those old Tamko 3-tabs that looked like they’d been through a war, but the decking underneath was bone dry. Meanwhile, I’ve seen high-end architectural shingles curl up after one bad hail season. There’s something to be said for that old-school formula, even if it’s not much to look at. Midwest winters really separate the gimmicks from the real deal.
That’s wild—my house was built in the late 90s and the original Tamko shingles are still hanging on, even after a couple rough winters. I’ve wondered if it’s just luck or if those older shingles really were made tougher. Is there something about the way they used to make them, or is it just that newer stuff tries too hard to look fancy? I’m debating whether to go with basic 3-tabs again or try something “premium” when it’s time to replace.
Funny you mention that—I’ve got a similar situation with my place, built in ‘98. The original 3-tab Tamkos are still up there, and I keep thinking they’re gonna give out any year now, but nope. I do think the older stuff might’ve been made a bit sturdier, or maybe it’s just fewer additives back then? The new “designer” shingles look cool but I’ve heard mixed things about whether they actually last longer. I’m leaning toward basic 3-tabs again when it’s time, just for the sake of reliability and cost. Not sure I trust all the fancy marketing on the premium ones.
I get where you’re coming from about the old 3-tabs lasting, but have you looked into why the newer “designer” shingles get mixed reviews? Some of those architectural shingles actually have better wind ratings and thicker mats, which can help in rough weather. I’ve seen a few jobs where the upfront cost was higher, but the warranty and durability paid off over time. Any reason you’re leaning away from them besides the marketing? Sometimes the extra layers do make a difference, especially if you’re in a spot with big temperature swings.
