Roofing discussions and local services.

Best ways to protect home from extreme weather combo?

543 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Gotta admit, I put off checking mine way too long...until I found squirrels had turned my attic into their personal Airbnb. Lesson learned - regular checks save headaches (and eviction notices for furry freeloaders). Pizza afterward sounds about right, haha.


Reply
dev_cathy2786

Had a similar issue a few years back - raccoons instead of squirrels, though. Now I swear by sealing attic vents with sturdy mesh and trimming back any branches near the roof. Keeps critters out and helps weatherproof too... pizza definitely earned after that job.


Reply
maxa32

- Mesh and branch trimming def helps, but honestly, raccoons are basically furry ninjas...they'll find a way if they're determined enough.
- I tried the mesh thing last summer, and it worked great for weatherproofing, but I swear the raccoons took it as a personal challenge. Ended up reinforcing with metal flashing - ugly but effective.
- Also learned the hard way that pizza BEFORE the job is a rookie mistake...food coma + ladder = bad combo.
- For extreme weather though, I've found gutter guards and regular roof inspections do more heavy lifting than branch trimming alone. Just my two cents from a newbie homeowner who's already made every mistake in the book...


Reply
patriciawood158

"For extreme weather though, I've found gutter guards and regular roof inspections do more heavy lifting than branch trimming alone."

Gutter guards are definitely helpful, but I'd argue that proper attic insulation and ventilation might actually be more critical for extreme weather protection. Last winter, despite having gutter guards installed, ice dams still formed because my attic wasn't ventilated properly. Once I added soffit vents and improved insulation, the difference was night and day...no more leaks or ice buildup. Just something else to consider alongside your current methods.


Reply
thomasquantum25

Good call on the attic insulation and ventilation. Learned that lesson the hard way myself a couple winters ago - thought gutter guards alone would do the trick, but nope, ice dams had other ideas. After beefing up insulation and adding ridge vents, things improved dramatically. Still gotta give gutter guards credit though...cleaning soggy leaves in freezing weather isn't exactly my idea of fun, haha. Definitely worth tackling both angles if you can.


Reply

"Still gotta give gutter guards credit though...cleaning soggy leaves in freezing weather isn't exactly my idea of fun, haha."

Totally agree with you there - gutter guards are a lifesaver when it comes to avoiding that miserable chore. Good call on the ridge vents too; proper attic ventilation is often overlooked but makes a huge difference in preventing ice dams. One thing I'd add from experience is checking your soffit vents regularly. I've seen cases where insulation accidentally blocks airflow from the soffits, undermining the whole ventilation system. A quick inspection every now and then can save you headaches down the road. Sounds like you've got a solid setup now, though - nice work getting ahead of the problem.


Reply
vintage_ryan

Yeah, gutter guards definitely help, but they're not foolproof. I've had ice build up right over them during heavy storms. Learned the hard way to occasionally check for ice dams forming along the edges...just something to keep an eye on.


Reply
davideditor

Good point about gutter guards - seen plenty of ice dams form even with them installed. Couple winters ago, I found ice backing up under my shingles...not fun. Now I make sure attic insulation and ventilation are solid - helps keep roof temps even and reduces ice buildup.


Reply

"Now I make sure attic insulation and ventilation are solid - helps keep roof temps even and reduces ice buildup."

Yeah, insulation and ventilation definitely help, but honestly, sometimes even that's not enough. A few winters back, I had the insulation upgraded and vents checked - thought I was all set. Then we got hit with a nasty cycle of snow, thaw, refreeze...you know the drill. Ended up with ice dams anyway, though admittedly less severe than before.

What really made a difference for me was getting a roof rake. Sounds old-school, I know, but pulling off that heavy snow before it melts and refreezes has saved me from headaches (and costly repairs). Sure, it's a bit of hassle trudging out there after every big snowfall, but compared to dealing with leaks or damaged shingles? I'll take it any day. Just my two cents from someone who's been there...


Reply
cooking691

Roof rake's a solid suggestion, but honestly, I've seen mixed results. Had tenants who swore by it, others who barely made a dent. IMO, pairing it with heated cables along the roof edge is the real game changer - bit pricier upfront, but worth avoiding those nightmare ice dams...


Reply
hollyb57

Roof rake and cables are decent, but tbh, I think you're both overlooking the bigger picture here:

- Have you considered green roofs? I've seen firsthand how they absorb rainfall and slow runoff - huge help in preventing ice dams.
- Plus, they add insulation value, keeping your home warmer in winter and cooler in summer. Win-win.
- Admittedly, upfront costs can be steep, and yeah, they're heavier, so not every roof can handle it without reinforcement.
- Still, long-term savings on energy bills and reduced maintenance hassles might balance things out. Seen a couple neighbors go this route and they're pretty happy with the results.

Just throwing it out there as another angle to tackle extreme weather...


Reply

"Admittedly, upfront costs can be steep, and yeah, they're heavier, so not every roof can handle it without reinforcement."

That's exactly my concern with green roofs. While the environmental and insulation benefits are appealing, the structural reinforcement required can significantly inflate the initial investment. I looked into this option last year when replacing my shingles, and after consulting a structural engineer, the additional costs for reinforcing my older home's framing were substantial enough to outweigh potential long-term savings.

Instead, I opted for reflective shingles combined with improved attic ventilation and insulation. This approach was more budget-friendly and still noticeably reduced ice dam formation and heat loss. Green roofs might be ideal for new builds or homes already structurally suited for them, but for many existing homeowners - especially those on tighter budgets - the cost-benefit analysis doesn't always pan out favorably. Just something to consider before diving into such a major project...


Reply

- Good call on reflective shingles - I did something similar and noticed a big difference in attic temps.
- Also added storm shutters last year, which helped a ton during heavy winds.
- Curious if anyone's tried reinforcing windows or doors specifically for extreme weather...worth the hassle/cost?


Reply
language_jose

"Curious if anyone's tried reinforcing windows or doors specifically for extreme weather...worth the hassle/cost?"

Definitely worth it in my experience, especially if you're in an area prone to heavy storms. I reinforced my garage door a couple years ago after seeing a neighbor's get completely blown in. It wasn't cheap, but honestly, it gave me peace of mind during last year's hurricane season. Also, anyone considered green roofs? I've had one for about five years now - helps absorb rainwater and cuts down on heat buildup significantly.


Reply

Totally agree about reinforcing doors and windows - did mine last year, and I noticed a huge difference during recent storms. A couple extra points I'd toss in:

- Storm shutters are pretty underrated. I installed accordion-style shutters on the bigger windows, and it was way easier than dealing with plywood every time a storm rolls in. Definitely saves stress when forecasts get dicey.
- Weatherstripping around doors/windows can also help quite a bit. Seems minor, but it keeps wind-driven rain from sneaking in around the edges. Cheap fix, too.
- On green roofs...I've always been curious but haven't pulled the trigger yet. How's maintenance been? Heard mixed things about upkeep and leaks, so that's kept me hesitant.
- Another thing I've found helpful: keeping gutters clean and adding extensions or splash blocks to direct water away from the foundation. Sounds basic, but standing water near your house is no joke - learned that one the hard way after some basement flooding.

Also, quick anecdote on garage doors: my brother ignored reinforcing his garage door for years until a nasty storm buckled it inward - insurance covered some of it, but he still had a big headache dealing with repairs afterward. He finally upgraded to a reinforced door afterward, and he's kicking himself for waiting so long.

Overall, I'd say spending upfront on these protections pays off big-time down the road...especially if your area's weather seems to be getting more unpredictable like mine has lately.


Reply
skypaws210

Good points on the shutters - I was debating between accordion shutters and plywood, but your experience makes me lean toward shutters. Seems like a lot less hassle when you're already stressed about a storm coming.

About green roofs, I looked into them briefly too. From what I've read, they're great for insulation and runoff control, but yeah...maintenance seems tricky. A friend of mine installed one and loves it, but he admits it's more upkeep than he expected - mostly weeding and checking drainage regularly. No leaks yet though, so maybe it's just about getting the installation right?

And totally agree on gutters. When I moved in, mine were clogged badly, and the first heavy rain turned my yard into a swamp. Cleaning them out and adding extensions made a huge difference. Learned quickly that small fixes can save big headaches later.


Reply
danielk80

"Seems like a lot less hassle when you're already stressed about a storm coming."

You're spot-on about the shutters - plywood might seem cheaper upfront, but trust me, once you've wrestled with heavy sheets in gusty winds, you'll wish you'd gone accordion. Plus, plywood storage is a pain. Accordion shutters just slide into place, lock down, and you're done. One less thing to worry about when you're already juggling storm prep.

On the green roof topic, your friend's experience sounds pretty typical. Installation is definitely key. I've seen a few green roofs installed, and the ones that hold up best long-term usually have a solid waterproofing membrane underneath and a good drainage system in place from day one. The tricky part is getting the slope and drainage layers right. Too flat, and water pools up; too steep, and your plants struggle. Also, choosing the right plants makes a huge difference. Sedums and other drought-tolerant ground covers usually need less weeding and maintenance overall. But yeah, even with the best setup, you'll still have to check drainage channels regularly and pull weeds occasionally. It's not exactly set-it-and-forget-it.

As for gutters, man, they're underrated for sure. I remember one job where the homeowner had ignored gutter maintenance for years. First heavy storm after I started working there, water was literally cascading down the walls, pooling around the foundation...total mess. After we cleared out the leaves and debris, we installed some simple leaf guards and extensions to direct water away from the house. Problem solved, yard dry again, homeowner happy. It's amazing how a little preventative maintenance can save you from big headaches later on.

If you're thinking about other storm-proofing upgrades, you might also consider checking your roof's flashing and seals around vents and skylights. Those are common weak points that people overlook until water starts dripping into the attic. A quick inspection and some fresh sealant can go a long way.

Good luck with your projects - sounds like you're on the right track already.


Reply

Accordion shutters are definitely convenient, but honestly, they're not always the best fit for every home. I've seen a few installations where the tracks warped slightly over time or got jammed up with dirt and debris, making them tough to close when you really need them. If you're going that route, just make sure you regularly clean and lubricate the tracks - especially if you're near the coast where salt spray can cause corrosion.

About green roofs...yeah, drainage is critical, but I'd argue plant selection matters even more. Sedums are great, but mixing in native grasses or wildflowers can actually improve root structure and stormwater absorption. It does mean a bit more maintenance at first, but long-term it can pay off in durability and runoff control.

And speaking of gutters - leaf guards aren't always foolproof. I've had clients who installed guards thinking they'd never have to clean again, only to find smaller debris still getting through and clogging things up. A quick seasonal check is still worth your time...beats dealing with water damage later on.


Reply

Totally agree on the accordion shutters getting jammed - I had a neighbor who struggled to close his during a storm because he hadn't cleaned them in ages. Lesson learned there. And good call on mixing wildflowers into green roofs; I've seen a few around town and they look amazing plus handle heavy rains surprisingly well. Leaf guards did save me some headaches, but yeah...still gotta do a quick check every now and then. Better safe than sorry with water damage, right?


Reply
nature_susan

Good points about the shutters and leaf guards. I've seen similar issues with accordion shutters - especially if they're aluminum, corrosion can really sneak up on you if maintenance slips. Green roofs are definitely interesting, though I'm curious how they hold up long-term in regions with harsh winters or heavy snowfall. Has anyone had experience with that? I've heard mixed things about their durability under prolonged freezing conditions or ice buildup. Also, speaking of gutters and leaf guards...has anyone tried heated gutter cables to prevent ice dams? Seems like a smart idea in theory, but I'm wondering if they're worth the investment or just another thing that needs constant checking.


Reply
Scroll to Top