Roofing discussions and local services.
Discussion options
thinking about upgrading shingles, but is the pro version really worth it?
So, I've been thinking lately about replacing the shingles on my roof. They're getting kinda old and worn out, and honestly, I'm tired of worrying every time there's a heavy storm. Anyway, I was talking to my neighbor (who's one of those guys who researches EVERYTHING before he buys), and he mentioned these Landmark shingles he's got on his roof. He swears by them. But then he says something like "but if you're gonna do it, might as well go with the pro version."
Now I'm stuck wondering - what exactly makes the "pro" version so much better? Is it just marketing hype or is there some real benefit to spending the extra cash? Like, are they seriously tougher or longer-lasting? Or is it mostly cosmetic - like fancier colors or textures or something?
I was thinking about it earlier and had this random scenario pop into my head: imagine two neighbors in a suburban cul-de-sac. One goes with standard Landmark shingles, the other splurges on the pro version. Over time, they start this friendly rivalry - comparing whose roof looks better after storms, whose shingles fade less in the sun, or whose house gets more compliments from visitors. Maybe they even get a little obsessed with it, you know? Like sneaking out at night to inspect each other's roofs with flashlights or drones or something... I dunno, it just seemed funny in my head.
Anyway, I'm curious if anyone here has experience with either of these shingles. Would love to hear your thoughts or maybe even continue that little story idea if you're feeling creative.
Join the conversation
Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.
8 replies
"imagine two neighbors in a suburban cul-de-sac. One goes with standard Landmark shingles, the other splurges on the pro version."
Haha, your little scenario cracked me up...reminds me of my dad and his neighbor who had this ongoing lawn rivalry. Anyway, I've used both versions (standard on my old house, pro on my current one). Honestly, the pro shingles do seem thicker and sturdier - especially noticeable after storms. Not sure if it's worth the extra cash for everyone, but I sleep better knowing they're up there.
Interesting perspective, and I totally get the peace-of-mind factor you're talking about. But I'm wondering if the pro shingles are really that much better in practice, or if it's more of a psychological thing?
"Honestly, the pro shingles do seem thicker and sturdier - especially noticeable after storms."
I've seen this mentioned a lot, but from what I've read and experienced myself, standard Landmark shingles already hold up pretty well in most storm conditions. I helped my brother reroof his place a few years back, and we went with the standard version. They've been through some pretty nasty weather - heavy rain, wind gusts, even hail - and they're still looking solid. No leaks or noticeable damage yet.
I guess my question is: how often are you really going to encounter storms severe enough to justify the extra cost? If you're in an area prone to extreme weather regularly, then sure, maybe it's worth it. But for most suburban neighborhoods, I'm not convinced the upgrade is necessary.
Also, something else to consider: proper installation matters just as much (if not more) than shingle thickness or quality. Even premium shingles can fail prematurely if they're not installed correctly. I'd personally put more effort into finding a reliable contractor who knows their stuff rather than splurging on upgraded materials.
Just my two cents...but I'd be curious to hear if anyone has had actual issues with standard shingles failing prematurely under normal suburban conditions.
You bring up a good point about installation - I totally agree that's key. From my experience, standard shingles are usually fine for most neighborhoods. Unless you're regularly getting hammered by severe storms, the upgrade might be more peace-of-mind than practical necessity...
From my experience, standard shingles are usually fine for most neighborhoods. Unless you're regularly getting hammered by severe storms, the upgrade might be more peace-of-mind than practical nece...
Good points above about installation quality, but honestly, from managing multiple properties, I've found the pro shingles actually do make a noticeable difference. They're thicker, usually have better warranties, and hold up longer against wind and hail. Cosmetic stuff aside, if you're planning to stay in your house long-term, I'd say it's worth the extra upfront cost. It's not just hype - you're paying for durability and fewer headaches down the road.
- Good points, but honestly, as a first-time homeowner, I'm not convinced yet.
- I mean, sure, thicker shingles sound great and all...but how often do roofs really fail early if they're installed right?
- Feels a bit like buying the extended warranty on electronics - nice to have, but usually not needed.
- Maybe I'll regret this later (famous last words?), but for now, standard shingles seem good enough for me.
I get the hesitation - upgraded shingles do feel like a bit of a luxury sometimes. But from what I've seen, roofs rarely fail early due to materials alone. Usually, it's sloppy installation or bad ventilation that causes issues. Standard shingles should honestly hold up fine if installed properly.
Good points, but I'd say the upgraded shingles aren't just about longevity. They usually offer better reflectivity and insulation, which can lower your energy bills over time. Plus, let's be real - standard shingles might be fine, but the pro versions do look pretty sharp on a house...
Fair enough, the pro shingles do have that sleek look going for them. But honestly, how noticeable is the reflectivity difference in real-world terms? I've managed properties with both types, and while the upgraded ones definitely have some perks (and yeah, they look pretty sweet), I'm still on the fence about whether the energy savings are significant enough to justify the extra upfront cost. Anyone here actually tracked their energy bills before and after switching?