"One thing I'd add is to double-check local distributors for availability. Around here at least, CertainTeed colors can sometimes be backordered, which throws off scheduling big-time."
Good call on checking availability—seen more than a few projects stall out because the chosen shingle color was suddenly nowhere to be found. From an inspection standpoint, both brands can perform well if installed correctly, but installation quality and proper venting are usually the real difference-makers.
If you're leaning toward CertainTeed, make sure your installer is certified or at least familiar with their specific guidelines. I've noticed their warranty claims process goes smoother when you have documented proof of proper installation steps (like correct nail placement and ventilation setup). Tamko's Heritage line is solid too, especially if budget is a factor. Just be sure your roofer follows manufacturer instructions closely—I've seen some premature wear issues pop up from simple oversights.
And yeah... coffee grounds as debris? Wish I'd thought of that sooner. Beats picking ketchup packets out of gutters any day.
Definitely agree about checking availability—ran into that exact issue last summer. We picked out a CertainTeed color, scheduled everything, then found out it was backordered for weeks. Ended up switching to Tamko Heritage instead, and honestly, it's been great so far. Installation quality is key, though... make sure your roofer doesn't cut corners on venting or flashing. Learned that the hard way with our previous roof.
Did you notice much difference in warranty coverage between the two brands? I've seen some roofers push CertainTeed because of their warranty, but honestly, from what I've seen, Tamko holds up pretty well too. Totally agree on installation quality though—seen plenty of roofs fail early just because someone skipped proper venting or flashing. Did your roofer recommend any specific venting setup, ridge vents vs box vents, etc.? Curious what worked best for you.
Warranty differences can be a bit misleading sometimes... had a neighbor who went with CertainTeed specifically for the warranty, but when storm damage hit, turns out wind damage wasn't fully covered without extra rider coverage. Tamko might not have the flashy warranty marketing, but I've seen them hold up just fine through some nasty weather. Honestly, the venting setup probably matters more—my roofer swore by ridge vents for better airflow, and so far, no issues. Curious if others had different experiences though.
Had a similar experience with CertainTeed—great shingles overall, but warranty fine print can be tricky. Tamko's been solid for me too, even through some rough storms. Totally agree on ridge vents though... proper airflow makes a huge difference in longevity.
