When I ran the numbers, the upfront difference was noticeable, but factoring in fewer repairs and better durability made CertainTeed worth it for me.
Good point—I got a small discount, nothing huge, but every bit helps..."Have you checked if your insurance offers any discounts for higher-rated shingles?"
Did you factor in warranty coverage differences? I went with CertainTeed myself a few years back, mostly because my neighbor had Tamko shingles and ended up dealing with warranty headaches when some issues popped up. Wasn't a huge deal-breaker, but it did sway me. Also, insurance gave me a minor discount too—not much, but hey, better than nothing...
Warranty coverage is definitely something you want to dig into carefully. Did you check the fine print on the Tamko warranty? I've seen homeowners get caught off guard by certain exclusions or prorated terms...just something worth double-checking before you commit.
Warranty's important, but honestly, brand reputation and real-world performance matter a lot more. I've installed plenty of Tamko roofs that held up just fine—sometimes warranties are more marketing than anything. I'd look at local installer's feedback over fine print details any day.
"sometimes warranties are more marketing than anything."
Couldn't agree more with this. I've inspected plenty of roofs over the years, and honestly, the difference often comes down to installation quality rather than brand alone. Seen Tamko roofs holding up beautifully after storms, and CertainTeed ones too...but also seen both fail prematurely when installed poorly. You're spot on about checking local installer reviews—real-world feedback beats warranty promises every time. Good luck with your decision, sounds like you're already on the right track.
