Roofing discussions and local services.

 
Discussion options
Discussion options
[#935]

How should I itemize ice-dam upgrades in a reroofing quote?

I’m planning a roof replacement and want to compare the cost of treating the causes of recurring ice dams rather than pricing only new shingles. The existing roof’s age and covering type, attic insulation level, soffit and ridge ventilation, and any previous ice-dam damage should all be reflected in the scope, but I’m not sure how contractors normally separate those allowances.

I’d like each proposal to show the roof covering and underlayment separately from:

- attic air-sealing work
- added or replaced insulation
- soffit, ridge, or other ventilation changes
- ice-barrier improvements at the eaves and vulnerable roof transitions
- repairs to any ice-dam-related interior or decking damage

For each item, should I request separate material and labor allowances, along with assumptions about how much insulation or ventilation work is included? I’m also trying to distinguish upgrades that address the attic’s heat and moisture movement from optional improvements that mainly add protection during a severe winter.

What level of detail would make these quotes genuinely comparable, especially when the roofer and insulation contractor may be different companies?


Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

5 replies

Since the roofer and insulation contractor may be separate, can each quote name who coordinates the work and how gaps or overlapping responsibilities will be handled? For example, who confirms the air-sealing and ventilation scope is complete before the roof work closes off access? That responsibility matters as much as the separate allowances when comparing bids.


Reply
peanuts22

Naming who coordinates the handoff is useful, but it won’t make the bids comparable by itself. I’d also want the insulation scope stated as a target R-value or specified depth and coverage, and the ventilation scope tied to a stated design basis and quantities. Otherwise, two contractors can both promise to “improve ventilation” while pricing quite different work.


Reply

Could each bid break out ice-barrier work by location and extent, such as the eaves versus vulnerable roof transitions? That makes it easier to distinguish added protection against water backing up from the separate air-sealing, insulation, and ventilation work aimed at attic heat and moisture movement. A single “ice-dam upgrade” allowance could hide very different scopes.


Reply
peanuts22

The interior and decking damage line needs a little qualification: separate known repairs from concealed damage that can’t be assessed until tear-off. For the concealed decking, ask for a unit price per sheet or square foot, a clear definition of what warrants replacement, and a note on whether the contractor needs approval before proceeding. That gives you a way to compare the potential extra cost without pretending anyone knows the repair quantity in advance.


Reply
mario_miller

The ventilation line is worth treating as a design decision, not an automatic “more is better” upgrade. Ask each bidder to state the proposed net free vent area and how intake and exhaust are balanced against the attic’s existing setup and the design basis they’re using. If the attic already meets that basis, extra ice-barrier coverage can be priced as added protection against water backing up in severe conditions, not presented as a fix for heat escaping into the attic. That keeps the cause-focused work distinct from the backup plan.


Reply
Scroll to Top