-
Couldn’t agree more. I’ve seen “temporary” patches last years, and “permanent” fixes fail after one storm.Hail is basically nature’s way of pointing out all your shortcuts.
- Stainless screws are a solid bet, but even those can rust if the coating chips.
- Gutters that don’t clog? Still a myth in my book. Leaf guards help, but then you’re just unclogging the guards instead.
- If your attic sags with Christmas lights, maybe skip the green roof for now... unless you want a rooftop garden in your living room.
Hail’s definitely a stress test for any roof, no matter how “permanent” the fix. I switched to standing seam metal after my asphalt shingles got shredded in a freak June storm—figured I was set for life. Turns out, even that’s not immune. Dents everywhere, and the seams took a beating where I’d used cheaper fasteners on a few panels. Lesson learned: those tiny shortcuts come back to haunt you. And gutters… I’ve tried every guard out there. They just turn into squirrel playgrounds or get jammed with pine needles anyway.
Lesson learned: those tiny shortcuts come back to haunt you.
Ain’t that the truth. I went with a cheaper metal myself, thinking it’d be “good enough” for our Midwest hail. Regret it every spring. Dents aren’t just cosmetic either—water started sneaking in at one seam where the fastener pulled loose. As for gutters, I gave up on guards after squirrels chewed through two brands. Now I just budget for a pro cleanout twice a year. Not perfect, but less hassle than fighting nature (and squirrels).
I hear you on the gutter guards. I thought I was clever with those mesh ones—turns out, the local raccoons are even more clever. They just rip them right off. As for metal roofs, I went with the “mid-tier” option thinking it’d be fine for our storms, but after last month’s hail, it looks like a golf ball up there. Not sure if I should laugh or cry every time it rains...
That raccoon story sounds way too familiar... I gave up on mesh guards after finding one halfway down the driveway. About the metal roof, did your warranty cover hail dents at all? I’ve heard some policies treat cosmetic damage differently than leaks or punctures. I’m in a similar spot—my “hail resistant” shingles didn’t hold up last spring, and now I’m wondering if it’s worth fighting with insurance or just living with the dings. Anyone had luck getting repairs covered for stuff that’s mostly just ugly, not actually leaking?
