- Agree on the paperwork—if they can’t show credentials, that’s a red flag.
- Clay’s durability in the sun is hard to beat, but yeah, it’s heavy. I’ve seen a few older homes where the rafters weren’t up for it.
- Structural check is smart, especially with houses pre-80s. Sometimes you find hidden issues (old termite damage, weird add-ons).
- Noticed concrete tile can be a good middle ground—lighter than clay, still holds up decently in heat. Worth considering if weight’s a concern.
Noticed concrete tile can be a good middle ground—lighter than clay, still holds up decently in heat. Worth considering if weight’s a concern.
Concrete tile’s definitely a solid compromise, especially if you’re worried about older rafters. I’d also throw in a plug for some of the newer composite tiles—brands like Brava or CeDUR are making products from recycled materials that mimic clay or slate but weigh a lot less. They’re pricier up front, but the environmental impact is lower and they’re easier on the structure. I’ve seen them hold up well in hot climates, though I’d still double-check local code approvals.
One thing I’d watch for: some concrete tiles can get pretty slick when wet, so if you’re in a rainy area, ask about surface texture.
I’ve been eyeing those composite tiles too—my neighbor put Brava on last year and swears by them, but the price tag made my wallet cry a little. Anyone actually compared how noisy they get in hail or heavy rain? My old asphalt roof sounded like a drumline during storms...
Anyone actually compared how noisy they get in hail or heavy rain? My old asphalt roof sounded like a drumline during storms...
That’s a good point—noise is one thing folks don’t think about until the first big storm hits. Did your neighbor mention if Brava was quieter than their old roof, or just better overall? I’ve seen composite tiles muffle sound more than metal, but sometimes it depends on the underlayment and attic insulation too. Anyone here ever tried adding extra insulation just to cut down on roof noise, or does that not make much difference in practice?
I totally get what you mean about the drumline effect—my old roof used to make me think hail was trying to break in. I did add some extra insulation in the attic, mostly for temperature, but it did seem to help with noise a bit. Not a miracle cure, but it took the edge off. I’ve heard composite tiles are quieter, but I guess it depends on how everything’s layered up there. Anyone else’s pets freak out less after a roof upgrade, or is mine just dramatic?
