Yeah, I hear you on the warranty stuff. I’ve seen more than a few homeowners get burned thinking they were covered, only to find out the “fine print” got them. One thing I’d add—CertainTeed does offer some upgraded warranties if you use their certified installers and all their products (like their underlayment, starter, etc.), but even then, you’re right, it’s not a magic shield.
I always tell folks, if you’re putting this much money into a roof, check references and make sure the crew actually does the details—proper flashing, ventilation, all that. That’s where I see most of the problems start, not the shingles themselves.
Curious, are you in an area that gets a lot of hail or wind? Sometimes it’s worth asking about impact-resistant shingles, even if they cost a bit more up front. Also, did you get any quotes that break down materials vs. labor? Sometimes you can save a bit by tweaking the underlayment or accessories, but you don’t want to cut corners on install. Just thinking out loud here...
I always tell folks, if you’re putting this much money into a roof, check references and make sure the crew actually does the details—proper flashing, ventilation, all that. That’s where I see most of the problems start, not the shingles themselves.
Couldn’t agree more about the details. I’ve seen some pretty pricey CertainTeed jobs go sideways because someone skipped a step on flashing or didn’t vent right. Honestly, the shingle brand almost becomes secondary if the install isn’t solid.
On the impact-resistant shingles—yeah, they’re not cheap, but I’ve seen them save folks a ton of hassle after a hailstorm. Insurance sometimes gives a break on premiums for those, but it really depends on your area and carrier. Curious if you’ve checked with your insurance about that? Sometimes they’ll even have a list of “approved” products.
About the quotes—did any of your bids actually spell out what underlayment and accessories they’re using, or is it just “CertainTeed system” as a blanket term? I’ve noticed some contractors get vague there, and it can make a difference in both price and warranty coverage. Just something to watch for.
About the quotes—did any of your bids actually spell out what underlayment and accessories they’re using, or is it just “CertainTeed system” as a blanket term?
That’s a good point. I had three different guys quote mine last year and two just lumped everything under “manufacturer’s system,” which felt a bit sketchy. Only one actually listed out the ice & water shield, synthetic underlayment, ridge vent, etc. Ended up going with him even though he was a little pricier—just felt better knowing what I was actually getting. Insurance did give me a small discount for impact-resistant, but it barely covered the price jump. Still, after last spring’s hail, I’m glad I did it.
I get wanting everything spelled out, but honestly, I went with a “system” quote and it worked out fine for me. The roofer walked me through what was included in person, even if it wasn’t on paper. Sometimes the detailed quotes just pad the price, you know? As long as you trust the crew and check their references, I don’t think you always need every single line item.
Yeah, I get that—sometimes those itemized quotes just make your eyes glaze over, and honestly, the “system” approach can be totally legit if you’ve done your homework on the crew. One thing I’d toss in, though: if you’re interested in green or energy-efficient options, it’s worth asking about what’s actually included. Some roofers will swap in recycled underlayment or reflective shingles if you ask, but they might not mention it unless you bring it up. Just my two cents from trying to make my own roof a little more eco-friendly…
