Curious if you've noticed a significant difference in lifespan between CertainTeed premium shingles and standard ones in moderate climates? I've been crunching numbers for my own roof replacement, and while moisture resistance is definitely key, I'm wondering if the extra upfront cost actually pays off over time. Did you see any noticeable performance gap after a few years, or was it mostly about peace of mind?
When we replaced ours, I went through the same debate. Ended up going with the premium, mostly because the warranty was better and I figured we'd stay here awhile. But honestly, after about five years, I haven't noticed any huge difference visually or performance-wise compared to our neighbor's standard shingles. Maybe it'll show more down the line...but for now, seems like it's mostly about peace of mind and warranty coverage. Did you factor in insurance discounts at all?
We just replaced ours last summer and went with the standard shingles. Honestly, I stressed about it way too much at first, but after chatting with neighbors and friends, realized most folks didn't notice a huge difference either. Insurance discount was minimal for us, but every bit helps...
"Honestly, I stressed about it way too much at first, but after chatting with neighbors and friends, realized most folks didn't notice a huge difference either."
Haha, I totally get that stress. When we redid ours, I spent hours comparing colors and styles, thinking it would dramatically change the look of our house. Spoiler alert: it didn't. Most people barely noticed we'd done anything unless I pointed it out... and even then, the reaction was usually just a polite nod.
But here's something worth considering: while the aesthetics might not be super noticeable to neighbors, the quality difference can matter long-term. CertainTeed has different tiers, and their higher-end shingles often come with longer warranties and better resistance against storms or hail. If you're in an area prone to rough weather, it might be worth spending the extra cash upfront for peace of mind.
Just my two cents—sometimes the stuff you can't immediately see ends up being the most valuable investment down the road.
Yeah, I went through the same thing—spent way too long agonizing over color samples and shingle styles. In the end, neighbors barely noticed. But honestly, after a couple rough winters, I'm glad we went with the higher-tier shingles. Peace of mind counts for something...
