I went with standard Landmark shingles about 8 years ago and haven't regretted it. My neighbor upgraded to the Pro line around the same time, and honestly, I can't see much difference in appearance or durability. We both have similar shading and weather exposure. Agree on the copper strips though—I installed some after noticing minor algae buildup around year 5, and they've kept it at bay ever since. Saved me from spending extra upfront on premium shingles.
I went with Landmark Pro on a couple properties I manage, and honestly, I'm kinda with you—hard to justify the extra cost. They look nice, sure, but standard Landmark shingles hold up just fine from what I've seen. Copper strips are definitely underrated though. Had one building that was turning into algae central after just 3 years... installed copper strips and problem solved. I'd say stick with standard shingles and spend the savings on copper strips or better underlayment instead.
"I'd say stick with standard shingles and spend the savings on copper strips or better underlayment instead."
I get where you're coming from, but I'd push back a bit on dismissing the Landmark Pro shingles outright. Yeah, they're pricier, but I've inspected a fair share of roofs, and there's a noticeable difference in durability and granule retention over time. Standard Landmark shingles are solid, no doubt, but if you're in an area with harsher weather—heavy storms, hail, or intense sun exposure—the Pro line can actually pay off in the long run.
That said, totally agree with you on copper strips being underrated. Algae buildup is no joke, and I've seen plenty of roofs prematurely age because of it. Copper strips are a smart investment, especially if your property has shade or moisture issues. But here's something else to consider: ventilation. A lot of folks overlook proper attic ventilation, and honestly, it's just as important as the shingles themselves. I've seen roofs with premium shingles fail early because the attic was trapping heat and moisture. So, if you're budgeting, maybe factor in a bit extra for ridge vents or soffit vents if your place needs them.
Bottom line, if your budget's tight and algae is your main concern, your approach makes sense. But if you're looking at long-term durability and fewer headaches down the road, Landmark Pro shingles might still be worth the extra cash. Just my two cents from crawling around on roofs all day...
Good points all around. I've been leaning toward standard shingles myself due to budget, but now you've got me thinking about ventilation.
"A lot of folks overlook proper attic ventilation..."
Guilty as charged—never really thought much about it. Is upgrading ventilation something DIY-friendly, or better left to the pros?
Ventilation upgrades can be DIY-able, but honestly, it depends on your comfort level and roof setup. I remember helping a buddy who thought he could handle ridge vents himself—ended up spending a weekend patching leaks after the first rainstorm. Not saying that'll happen to you, just that attic ventilation isn't always as straightforward as it seems. If you're handy and cautious, go for it...otherwise, might save headaches (and drywall repairs) by getting someone experienced to tackle it.
