That’s been my experience too—metal’s tough in wind, but those seams are a weak spot if the installer cuts corners. Last year after a hailstorm, I fou...

Had a similar experience with synthetic underlayment after a nasty windstorm last year—saved my attic from turning into a swimming pool. I do miss how...

I get why folks lean toward tear-offs—you really do get peace of mind knowing what’s under there. But I’ll be honest, I went with a second layer a few...