- Same here, foam’s a pain for finding leaks. - - I’ve tried the “smell test” too—sometimes you catch it, sometimes not. - One thing that helpe...

- — seriously, every time I read “active moisture intrusion” I picture a waterfall in my attic. - Did you find cedar shakes actually last longer? I k...

- Had the same thing last winter—roof looked totally fine, but got these weird brownish stains on the bedroom ceiling. - —yeah, learned that the har...

- Totally agree, felt is cheap up front but I’ve had to patch it more than I’d like. - Midwest winters here too—ice dams are brutal. My shed roof wi...

- Totally get it— That’s my hangup too. - Looked at “coastal” metal, but the price jump is wild. Still see rusty spots on neighbors’ roofs after 8-10 ...

- Totally agree about the “thermal anomaly” thing—mine flagged a spot last summer, but it was just where my kid left a soccer ball up there. Not exact...

- Totally agree, aluminum does seem to hold up better than steel—at least for a while. - I’ve noticed powder coating helps, but after a couple years t...