Maybe I just have lower standards for attic plumbing than most folks.
I get where you’re coming from—sometimes you just need to slap a band-aid on it and deal with the “real” fix later. I’ve definitely been in those situations where you’re balancing on a rafter, water dripping down your back, and all you want is for the leak to stop for five minutes. Still, I’ve learned the hard way that those quick fixes can come back to haunt you, especially in places like attics where you don’t check as often.
Had a tenant once who used a push-to-connect fitting on a copper line up in the crawlspace. Worked fine for a few weeks, but then it started leaking again—quietly, behind insulation. By the time anyone noticed, there was mold and a warped ceiling below. That “bought time” ended up costing way more in repairs.
Not saying slow and steady is always possible (sometimes you just gotta survive the storm), but I try to at least circle back sooner than later. Attic plumbing’s out of sight, out of mind... until it isn’t.
I get the concern about “band-aid” fixes, but honestly, sometimes those push-to-connect fittings are a lifesaver—especially if you’re not a pro with a torch. I know they’re not perfect, but for a lot of us, it’s either that or let the leak keep going until we can get someone in.
“That ‘bought time’ ended up costing way more in repairs.”
Fair point, but I’d argue that with modern fittings, if you install them right and double-check, they can hold up for years. Maybe not forever, but not every “quick fix” is doomed to fail. I’d rather patch it up and monitor than risk a bigger mess waiting for the “perfect” repair.
Had a house last winter where the owner used a push-to-connect on a copper line behind the fridge. Looked fine, no leaks when I checked. Six months later, I’m back for a different issue and that same fitting is still bone dry. I get the worry about “band-aid” fixes, but
That’s been my experience too—sometimes you just need to stop the water, not win a plumbing contest.“if you install them right and double-check, they can hold up for years.”
Push-to-connects have saved me more than once, especially when you just need to get the water going again and there’s no time for sweating joints. I get the hesitation—some folks think they’re just a quick fix, but if it’s dry after six months, that’s proof enough for me. Makes me wonder though, where do you draw the line? Like, I’ve seen people use roofing tape as a “temporary” patch that lasts years... is that cutting corners, or just being practical?
I get where you’re coming from—push-to-connects are a lifesaver in a pinch. But I’ve seen a few “temporary” fixes turn into long-term headaches, especially with stuff like roofing tape. Had a spot over my porch patched that way, and it held up for almost two years… until a big storm hit and water started pouring in. Sometimes those quick fixes buy you time, but I try not to let them become the permanent solution. Guess it depends on how much risk you’re willing to take, but I’m a little more cautious after that mess.
