Haha, tile roofs being maintenance-free is a classic homeowner myth—right up there with "gutters clean themselves after a good rain." I remember a guy who swore his tile roof was bombproof...until a squirrel decided to stash acorns under the tiles. Rainwater backed up, and suddenly he had a surprise indoor waterfall. Tiles are tough, sure, but nature finds a way. A little TLC every now and then saves a lotta headaches later.
Tile roofs definitely aren't bulletproof, but honestly, they're pretty close to maintenance-free compared to other options. I've seen plenty of roofs hold up beautifully for decades with minimal fuss. Sure, squirrels and debris can cause issues, but that's more about surroundings and less about the tiles themselves. A quick inspection every year or two usually does the trick. Nature's creative, but tile roofs still beat most alternatives hands-down in terms of durability and low hassle.
Totally agree with you on tile roofs being low-maintenance. Had mine for about 15 years now, and honestly, aside from the occasional cracked tile after a heavy storm, it's been smooth sailing. One thing I'd add though—make sure your flashing and underlayment are solid. Tiles themselves last forever, but if the stuff underneath isn't done right, you'll still run into leaks eventually. Learned that the hard way... Still, compared to shingles or metal, tile's a no-brainer for durability and peace of mind.
Tile roofs are definitely solid, but I wouldn't call them totally maintenance-free. Had mine about 10 years, and while they're way less hassle than shingles, you still gotta keep an eye out for moss buildup or debris getting stuck between tiles—especially if you've got trees nearby. Agree 100% on the underlayment though; cutting corners there will cost you big time later. Still, even with minor upkeep, tile's worth it in the long run for durability and resale value.
Good points about the moss and debris—I recently bought a house with a tile roof, and I've already noticed leaves piling up after storms. Still, glad to hear the upkeep isn't too demanding overall; makes me feel better about my choice.
