insulation and airflow are way more important here in the Midwest than some fancy new roof tech
I get where you’re coming from, but have you looked into green or living roofs at all? I know they sound “fancy,” but sometimes they actually help with insulation and can be DIY’d on a budget. Wondering if anyone’s tried that in a Midwest winter—does it hold up, or just turn into a soggy mess?
- Good point about green roofs—I've seen a couple in Chicago, but honestly, Midwest winters are brutal.
- Heard mixed things: some folks say the extra soil helps with insulation, others complain about drainage issues and ice dams.
- If you DIY, make sure your structure can handle the weight. Wet soil plus snow gets heavy fast.
- Still, I like the idea. Anything that helps with insulation is worth a look, especially with energy prices lately.
- Not sure I'd risk it on an older roof, though... might be asking for trouble if there's already storm damage or leaks.
If you DIY, make sure your structure can handle the weight. Wet soil plus snow gets heavy fast.
That’s a big concern for me too. My house is about 60 years old, and I’m not sure the rafters would be up for that kind of load, especially after a wet winter. Has anyone here reinforced their roof before adding something like this? I’ve only ever done minor repairs—never anything structural. Wondering if it’s even worth considering or if I should just stick with more traditional insulation upgrades.