- Carried those architectural bundles up a two-story once—my arms were noodles for days.
- Tried the composite “slate” on a porch last fall. Way lighter, cuts easier, but didn’t love the way it flexed on steeper pitches.
- Looks-wise, they fooled my neighbor, but up close you can tell they’re not real slate.
- Install was quick, though, and no shoulder pain... so there’s that.
Install was quick, though, and no shoulder pain... so there’s that.
That “no shoulder pain” part is a big win in my book. I looked at composite slate too—price was way easier on the wallet than real slate or even metal. It’s true, up close you can tell it’s not the real deal, but honestly, I’d rather have something I can actually afford and install without hiring a small army. My only gripe is how hot they get in the sun—my porch felt like a frying pan last July. Still, beats climbing up there with 80-pound bundles...
That quick install is honestly a dream. I’m with you—lifting those heavy bundles is for the birds, especially if you’re doing it solo. The heat thing is real, though. Have you noticed if the attic gets warmer too, or is it just the porch? I’ve got asphalt shingles and they definitely trap heat in the summer. Still, not having to shell out for a full slate roof feels like a solid tradeoff, at least for my budget. Ever think about adding some shade or maybe lighter colors to help with the heat?
- Quick installs are a lifesaver, especially when you’re working alone in the heat.
- Asphalt shingles do tend to make attics warmer—depends on ventilation, though. Some houses I’ve worked on barely notice, others feel like a sauna up there.
- Lighter colors can help, but not everyone likes the look. Shade trees or even a simple awning over the porch can make a difference.
- Ever tried adding more vents or a ridge vent to your attic? Sometimes that’s enough to drop the temp a few degrees.
I get the point about lighter shingles, but honestly, I think attic ventilation matters way more than color. I’ve seen dark roofs stay cooler just because the airflow up there was dialed in right. Shade helps, but if the air’s trapped, it’s still an oven.
