- I've mixed auction sheets with new ones a couple times, and honestly, it turned out better than expected.
- Trick is to group similar shades or textures together, so the differences aren't glaringly obvious.
- Also helps if you can place the mismatched sections in less visible areas—like the back or sides of the property.
- One thing I'd caution though: auction sheets sometimes have subtle differences in thickness or coating quality, which can affect longevity.
- Have you considered painting or coating afterward to unify the look? Curious if anyone's tried that and how it held up over time...
I've seen a few roofs where people tried painting over mixed sheets, and honestly, it didn't always age well. Ever notice how paint fades unevenly or starts peeling quicker on certain sections? Might be worth considering before going that route...
"Ever notice how paint fades unevenly or starts peeling quicker on certain sections?"
Yeah, I've definitely noticed that too. When we first moved into our place, the previous owners had painted over mixed metal sheets, and within a couple of years, it looked patchy and worn out. Honestly, if you're investing in a new roof, might as well get matching sheets from the start. It'll save you headaches down the road... and probably money too. Good luck with your roofing project—it's worth doing right the first time.
Same thing happened to us. When we bought our house, the previous owner had done a quick DIY paint job on the metal roof—looked decent at first, but after just one winter it started peeling in random patches. Turns out they hadn't prepped the surface properly or used the right primer. Ended up replacing the whole thing last summer...lesson learned, I guess. Better to spend a bit more upfront than deal with constant touch-ups later on.
Replacing the roof entirely does sound like a solid long-term fix, but I wonder if you've considered eco-friendly coatings as an alternative? Properly applied elastomeric coatings, for example, can significantly extend the life of metal roofs and improve energy efficiency. I've seen cases where, with thorough surface prep and the right primer, these coatings held up beautifully for years—even in tough climates. Might've saved you some hassle and expense...though I totally understand wanting to avoid constant touch-ups.
