I get where you’re coming from, but I’ve actually had better luck with the big box stores lately. Last time I bought panels, everything was wrapped tight and not a single dent. Local yard near me, though, had a pile of scratched-up ones...guess it depends on the staff and how busy they are. I do miss being able to hand-pick, but sometimes convenience wins out.
I’ve noticed the same thing—big box stores seem to have their act together with packaging lately. But I always wonder about the gauge and coating quality compared to what the local yards carry. Did you notice any difference in the specs or just went with what was on the shelf? I’m picky about getting panels that’ll last, but sometimes my wallet says otherwise...
I get where you’re coming from—sometimes the price tags at the big stores are tempting, but I’ve noticed the panels can be a bit thinner than what I’ve picked up at local yards. I usually end up comparing the labels side by side, but honestly, it’s not always apples to apples. My last project, I went with the local yard because the coating warranty was better, even though it cost a bit more. It’s tough balancing quality and budget, but I think you’re right to be picky if you want it to last.
That’s a good point about the warranties—sometimes the local yards really do offer better specs, especially on coatings and thickness. I’ve run into issues with big box panels denting more easily, which is a headache if you’re managing multiple properties. The gauge can make a real difference, but it’s not always obvious from the shelf labels. I usually ask for the spec sheet or mill certs if I’m unsure... not every supplier loves that, but it’s saved me from some headaches down the line. Price matters, but so does not having to replace panels in five years.
You’re spot on about the gauge and coatings—those details really do make a difference over time. I’ve had similar problems with the lighter panels from the big box stores, especially after a hailstorm last year. The local supplier wasn’t thrilled when I asked for mill certs either, but it paid off. Sometimes you just have to push for the info, even if it feels awkward. Spending a bit more upfront has definitely saved me from replacing dented panels way too soon.
