Our inspector actually crawled into the attic—full hazmat vibes, since we’d heard some scratching up there last winter. He found a couple of old nests but nothing active, thankfully. I was half-expecting him to come down with a squirrel clinging to his leg. Insurance company still grilled us about tree branches and “potential entry points,” but after the inspection report, they dropped our premium by almost $200 a year. Not bad for an hour’s work.
I get what you mean about them looking for excuses, though. My neighbor had a similar inspection and somehow ended up with a higher rate because they found an old patch job on his roof. Seems like it’s a bit of a roll of the dice... guess it depends who you get and how picky they are that day.
Still, I’ll take my win—just hoping the squirrels don’t unionize and start charging rent.
That’s a solid outcome, especially these days when insurance companies seem to look for any excuse to hike rates. I’ve seen both sides of this—sometimes a clean attic and a few trimmed branches can make all the difference, other times they’ll nitpick every little thing. The part you mentioned about your neighbor getting dinged for an old patch job? That’s way too common.
“My neighbor had a similar inspection and somehow ended up with a higher rate because they found an old patch job on his roof.”
Honestly, patch jobs aren’t always a red flag if they’re done right, but some inspectors just see “repair” and assume there’s a bigger issue. I always tell folks, document everything—photos, receipts, even before/after shots if you DIY. It helps if you ever have to push back.
And yeah, those “potential entry points” questions are no joke. Squirrels, raccoons, you name it—they’ll find their way in if there’s even a tiny gap. I’ve pulled more than one nest out of soffits or under loose shingles. Still, $200 off a year is nothing to sneeze at. Just keep an eye on those trees and maybe invest in some heavy-duty mesh if the critters get bold...
Funny you mention inspectors and their eagle eyes—had a guy once who spent more time poking around my gutters than actually looking at the roof. He found a tiny patch from years back (barely bigger than a dinner plate) and started grilling me like I’d hidden a crime scene up there. Ended up having to dig out receipts and a couple of old phone pics just to prove it wasn’t a hack job. Still got a rate bump, though. Go figure.
I’ve seen both sides too—sometimes you get someone reasonable, other times it’s like they’re hunting for any excuse. And yeah, those “entry points” questions... had a raccoon family move in through a vent once. Took three weeks and a lot of mesh to convince them to relocate. Now I just assume anything bigger than a pencil is a potential animal highway.
Congrats on the $200 savings, by the way. Around here, that’s basically a free month of groceries. Just keep an eye on the little stuff—sometimes it’s the tiniest things that end up costing the most.
- Seen a lot of this over the years—some inspectors are almost too eager to find “gotchas.”
-
“He found a tiny patch from years back (barely bigger than a dinner plate) and started grilling me like I’d hidden a crime scene up there.”
Happens more than folks realize. They’ll zero in on old repairs, even if they’re holding up fine. Sometimes I think they’re just looking for an excuse to justify their fee or keep the insurance company happy.
- Gutters and vents are big targets, too. Had one guy focus on a bit of rust on my flashing and ignore the actual missing shingles right next to it. Go figure.
- Raccoons through vents—yep, classic. Squirrels are just as bad here, and once they get in, it’s a mess. Mesh is good, but I’ve also started using metal plates on the more vulnerable corners after a possum chewed through plastic.
- $200 savings is nothing to sneeze at these days. Around here, though, it’s hit or miss—sometimes you get dinged for stuff that’s been fixed for years, other times they barely look.
- One thing I’ve noticed: insurance companies seem to care more about “potential” issues than actual damage. Tiny cracks, loose seals, even slightly raised shingles—they’ll flag it all. Not sure if that’s better or worse than waiting until something actually fails.
- Curious—anyone ever had an inspector *miss* something major? Had a neighbor whose inspector gave him the all-clear, then two months later half his soffit blew off in a storm. Insurance tried to say it was “pre-existing” even though nobody caught it before.
- For what it’s worth, I keep a folder with photos of every repair and date-stamped receipts now. Not fun but saved my bacon during the last round of questions.
- Anyone else notice more nitpicking lately? Or is it just our area getting stricter?
“He found a tiny patch from years back (barely bigger than a dinner plate) and started grilling me like I’d hidden a crime scene up there.”
That’s pretty much par for the course these days. I get why they’re thorough, but sometimes it feels over the top. You’re smart to keep all those photos and receipts—same here, and it’s bailed me out more than once. The nitpicking does seem worse lately, but honestly, saving $200 is still a win. Just have to stay one step ahead of them, I guess.