Notifications
Clear all

Lowered my insurance bill after a roof inspection—anyone else surprised?

715 Posts
665 Users
0 Reactions
20.3 K Views
cocowilliams298
Posts: 6
(@cocowilliams298)
Active Member
Joined:

That’s a solid move—upgrading attic insulation and adding vents can make a bigger difference than folks expect, especially in older homes. I’ve seen a lot of 70s-era split-levels where the original insulation just doesn’t cut it anymore. Curious, did you notice any change in how even the temps are between floors after the upgrade? Sometimes those drafts are actually from poor attic air sealing, not just thin insulation. Wondering if you tackled any air leaks while you were up there or just focused on the insulation itself...


Reply
Posts: 4
(@richardj60)
New Member
Joined:

Sometimes those drafts are actually from poor attic air sealing, not just thin insulation.

I’ve seen that a lot—folks add insulation but skip sealing up the gaps around light fixtures or attic hatches. Did a job last winter where just hitting those leaks made the upstairs way less drafty. Insulation helps, but air sealing’s what really evens out temps between floors in my experience.


Reply
Posts: 6
(@michaelkayaker)
Active Member
Joined:

Insulation helps, but air sealing’s what really evens out temps between floors in my experience.

I’m starting to believe that. I just bought my place last fall and figured the chilly upstairs was just “old house problems.” Tossed a few more batts up there, but didn’t notice much difference. Then I read about all the weird spots air leaks through—like those tiny gaps around can lights or the attic hatch. Never thought something so small could make a room feel drafty.

Had a home energy audit (mostly because I was curious and, honestly, hoping for some free advice). The guy found cold air pouring in around the attic stairs and bathroom vent. He sealed them up with some foam and gaskets, and suddenly my bedroom wasn’t an icebox every morning.

Still not sure why insurance companies care so much about roof stuff and not drafts, though. After my inspection, they knocked about $200 off my annual bill just because the shingles were newer than they thought. Meanwhile, nobody asks if you’re heating the neighborhood through your ceiling cracks.

Is it normal for insurance to drop rates just because of a roof inspection? I always assumed they’d only raise prices if they found something bad. Maybe I should send them photos every year… or would that backfire?

Anyway, if anyone else is dealing with uneven temps between floors, check for those weird little leaks before you go nuts adding more insulation. Learned that one the hard way—plus crawling around in an attic isn’t as fun as YouTube makes it look.


Reply
retro_zelda
Posts: 21
(@retro_zelda)
Eminent Member
Joined:

I had a similar experience after moving in—figured my drafty upstairs was just the way it goes with a 1950s house. I kept piling up insulation, but it barely helped. Once I started caulking around the attic hatch and sealing up the can lights, it made a way bigger difference than I expected.

As for insurance, I was surprised too. My rate dropped after I showed them proof the roof was only five years old. I honestly thought they’d use any excuse to raise my premium, not lower it. I’ve wondered if sending more photos would help or just open a can of worms... hard to say. Insurance logic is a mystery.


Reply
davidmentor
Posts: 9
(@davidmentor)
Active Member
Joined:

Title: Lowered my insurance bill after a roof inspection—anyone else surprised?

Yeah, insurance companies can be weirdly unpredictable. I’ve seen a lot of folks get a break on their premiums after showing proof of a newer roof, especially if it’s got impact-resistant shingles or meets newer codes. One thing I’d watch out for—sending too many photos sometimes backfires if they spot something minor and want it fixed. If your roof’s in good shape, though, it usually works in your favor. Just make sure you’ve got clear documentation and receipts. Insurance logic...definitely not straightforward.


Reply
Page 140 / 143
Share:
Scroll to Top