Roofing discussions and local services.

finally found a roofing company that didn't rip me off

346 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

"One thing I found helpful (and cheaper!) was just doing a thorough attic inspection after heavy rain."

That's a solid tip - attic checks after storms can reveal a lot. I've seen plenty of roofs that looked fine from outside but had hidden issues lurking underneath. Thermal imaging is cool, but like you said, it's usually overkill unless you're chasing down a stubborn leak or insulation problem.

Speaking of inspections, has anyone here tried moisture meters for checking suspect areas? They're pretty affordable now, and I've found them handy for pinpointing damp spots before they become visible stains or mold patches. Not as flashy as thermal cameras, but they can save you from bigger headaches down the road.

Glad to hear roofing companies are stepping up their transparency game in your area. Around here, it's still hit or miss...but maybe that's changing slowly. Did your roofer offer any kind of warranty or follow-up inspection after the job was done? Curious how common that's becoming these days.


Reply
minimalism_laurie

"Speaking of inspections, has anyone here tried moisture meters for checking suspect areas?"

I've used moisture meters a few times, and they're definitely handy for catching issues early. One thing I'd add though - make sure you're checking multiple spots around the suspected area. Moisture can travel along beams or insulation, so the wettest spot isn't always directly under the leak. Learned that the hard way after chasing a phantom leak for weeks... Has anyone else run into tricky leaks like that?


Reply
patriciawood158

Moisture meters are useful, but honestly I've found thermal imaging cameras more reliable for tricky leaks. Moisture meters sometimes give false positives if there's metal or wiring nearby... thermal imaging can pinpoint temperature differences and help narrow things down faster. Worth considering, maybe?


Reply

"Moisture meters sometimes give false positives if there's metal or wiring nearby..."

That's a great point - I've run into that issue myself a few times, especially around flashing or near electrical boxes. Thermal imaging definitely has its advantages, particularly when you're dealing with subtle leaks or insulation issues. I've found combining both methods can be helpful, though. Moisture meters for initial checks, then thermal imaging to confirm and pinpoint tricky spots. Glad you found a roofing company that's trustworthy; that's half the battle right there.


Reply

True, moisture meters can be a bit finicky around metal or wiring, but honestly, thermal imaging isn't foolproof either. I've seen thermal cameras pick up weird heat signatures from sunlight warming shingles or even someone's attic vent fan running - talk about chasing ghosts! Both methods definitely have their quirks, so it's always smart to double-check visually and with some good ol' fashioned experience. Glad you found a solid roofer though...finding one who's honest AND knows their stuff is like hitting the jackpot these days.


Reply
twriter23

"Both methods definitely have their quirks, so it's always smart to double-check visually and with some good ol' fashioned experience."

Couldn't agree more - I've had thermal imaging lead me down some rabbit holes myself. Once spent half an hour puzzling over a heat signature that turned out to be a sunlit chimney chase...lesson learned the hard way. Glad you found someone reliable, that's rare these days.


Reply
nalapupper196

Haha, thermal imaging can definitely trick you sometimes. A few years back, I spent way too long tracking down what I thought was a leak - turned out to be a warm spot from sunlight hitting metal flashing. Felt pretty silly afterward, but hey, that's how we learn, right? Glad you finally found a trustworthy roofer; good contractors are like gold these days.


Reply

Yeah, thermal imaging can definitely send you chasing ghosts sometimes. I remember the first time I used one on a roof inspection - I was convinced I'd found moisture trapped under the membrane. Spent ages carefully marking out the area, double-checking measurements, and even calling over my supervisor to confirm. Turned out it was just residual heat from an HVAC exhaust vent nearby... felt pretty embarrassed at the time, but honestly, that's the kind of mistake that sticks with you and makes you better in the long run.

Glad to hear you've finally landed a decent roofer, though. It can be tough sorting through contractors who seem legit but end up cutting corners or overcharging. A good one really does make all the difference in quality and peace of mind. Sounds like you're on solid ground now - nice work tracking them down.


Reply
cocogonzalez839

Yeah, thermal imaging can definitely trick you sometimes. I've had similar experiences - once spent half an afternoon convinced I'd found storm-related water intrusion, only to discover later it was just shaded areas cooling differently. Good learning experience, though. Curious, did your roofer mention anything about preventative measures against future storm damage? Some contractors skip that step, but it's usually worth the extra conversation...


Reply
robertwilliams621

Had a similar issue once - thermal imaging had me chasing shadows (literally) for hours. Did your roofer actually recommend specific preventative measures, or just vaguely mention them? I've found some contractors toss around buzzwords without giving concrete solutions...


Reply
tjackson79

Honestly, contractors tossing around buzzwords isn't always intentional vagueness - sometimes they're just trying to simplify things for homeowners. I've seen roofers genuinely recommend thermal imaging because it can pinpoint hidden moisture issues before they become nightmares. Sure, it's not foolproof (as you've clearly experienced), but dismissing it entirely seems shortsighted. Maybe your roofer wasn't clear enough, but that doesn't mean the tech itself is just hype. I'd say it's more about how clearly the contractor communicates the benefits and limitations upfront...


Reply
andrewlopez894

"I'd say it's more about how clearly the contractor communicates the benefits and limitations upfront..."

Exactly, clarity is key. Had a client once who was skeptical about thermal imaging until we walked through the scans together - step by step - and spotted moisture buildup early. It's all about setting realistic expectations upfront...


Reply
speak28

Yeah, thermal imaging can be a tough sell at first - had a similar experience myself. Client thought we were pulling some sci-fi nonsense until we showed him exactly where the insulation was failing. Once he saw the cold spots lining up perfectly with his leaks, he was sold. You're right though, it's all about being upfront about what tools can and can't do. Saves everyone headaches later on...


Reply
williamm77

"Client thought we were pulling some sci-fi nonsense until we showed him exactly where the insulation was failing."

Yeah, I've been there myself - had a homeowner convinced green roofs were just a trendy gimmick until I showed her how much cooler her neighbor's attic was mid-summer. Seeing really is believing sometimes...


Reply
tigger_rebel

Had something similar happen when I installed reflective attic foil. My neighbor thought I was just wasting money on shiny stuff until we compared attic temps on a 95-degree day... suddenly he was asking where to buy it, haha. Sometimes you just gotta show 'em the numbers.


Reply

"Sometimes you just gotta show 'em the numbers."

Exactly, data doesn't lie. I'll admit, I was pretty skeptical about reflective attic foil myself at first. It seemed like another gimmicky upsell product - shiny stuff that looks good but doesn't do much. But after helping install it on a customer's house last summer, I had to rethink my stance.

We checked the attic temps before and after installation, and the difference was actually impressive - around 15 degrees cooler on similarly hot days. Not saying it's some miracle fix or anything, but that's definitely enough to make a real impact on energy bills over time. Still think some companies hype it up way too much though... but yeah, when done right and combined with proper ventilation, it does seem worth it.

Funny how neighbors always roll their eyes until they see actual proof, huh? Guess we're all skeptics till we see it ourselves.


Reply
gingerw68

Yeah, I've seen similar results during inspections. Had one homeowner who swore by it - said his AC didn't kick on nearly as often afterward. It's not magic, but combined with decent insulation and airflow, it definitely helps shave off some costs over time.


Reply
johns79

Had a similar experience myself a couple years back. I was pretty skeptical at first - figured it was just another upsell tactic from the roofing guys. But after biting the bullet and getting the reflective shingles installed, I did notice a difference. Not night-and-day, mind you, but enough to make me think there might be something to it. My AC still kicks on plenty during those brutal summer afternoons, but it seems to cycle off quicker than before.

Still, like you said, it's probably more about the whole package - good insulation, proper attic ventilation, and all that jazz. I wouldn't call it a miracle fix by any stretch, but hey, every little bit helps when you're trying to keep those energy bills down. Glad you found a company that treated you right; that's half the battle these days...


Reply

"Still, like you said, it's probably more about the whole package - good insulation, proper attic ventilation, and all that jazz."

Yeah, that's been my experience too. I upgraded insulation first and noticed a bigger difference than when I switched shingles later. Makes me wonder if reflective shingles alone are really worth the extra cash...


Reply
cherylclimber

- Had the same thought about reflective shingles... seemed pricey for what they actually do.
-

"good insulation, proper attic ventilation, and all that jazz."
Definitely noticed insulation made the biggest difference here too.
- Wonder if anyone's tried radiant barriers instead - cheaper alternative maybe?


Reply
Scroll to Top