I put a metal roof, which is designed for strong wind and hail. The price was more expensive than usual, but I decided that in my region it is justified. In a couple of years the roof has never been damaged, even after a hurricane. In advertising a lot of exaggerations, but, honestly, it’s better to overpay a little and not worry about repair after each storm.
Metal roofs definitely have their advantages—durability being a big one. I've managed properties in some storm-heavy areas, and I can confirm that metal roofing usually holds up impressively well. But there's another factor I always consider: noise levels during heavy rain or hail. Some tenants have complained about the drumming sounds during storms, even with insulation and soundproofing measures.
Curious if you've noticed much noise from your roof during heavy rains or hailstorms? I've seen mixed reactions—some folks find it soothing, others can't stand it. Also wondering if anyone has experience with composite shingles or other alternatives specifically designed for extreme weather... I'm still comparing options for an upcoming project.
I've inspected plenty of houses with metal roofs, and you're right—durability is usually top-notch. But noise can definitely be a factor. I remember one inspection during a heavy downpour; the homeowner joked it sounded like a marching band was practicing overhead. Even with insulation, some people just can't get past that drumming sound.
Composite shingles can be a solid alternative. I've seen them hold up surprisingly well in areas prone to hailstorms or heavy winds. They're quieter, too, since they absorb impact better than metal. Another option I've noticed gaining popularity lately is rubber roofing—especially recycled rubber shingles. They seem to handle extreme weather pretty effectively and dampen noise significantly compared to metal.
Have you looked into those at all? They're not as common yet, but might be worth considering if noise is a big concern...
"Another option I've noticed gaining popularity lately is rubber roofing—especially recycled rubber shingles."
Yeah, rubber shingles are definitely underrated. We put them on our cabin about four years ago after a nasty hailstorm shredded our old asphalt roof. Honestly, they've been fantastic so far—quiet during storms and surprisingly tough. Plus, knowing they're recycled feels good too. I'd say they're worth a closer look if noise and durability are your main worries...
We considered rubber shingles too, but ended up going with metal roofing after weighing the pros and cons. Rubber definitely has its perks—like you said, quiet and eco-friendly—but metal seemed better suited for heavy snow loads in our area. Installation was straightforward enough if you're handy: just make sure your roof deck is solid, use proper underlayment, and don't skimp on fasteners. Four winters later, it's held up great...though I admit, rubber shingles still intrigue me.
"quiet during storms and surprisingly tough."
Maybe next project!
