Fair points all around, but just to throw another angle out there: - Premium shingles often come with way better warranties. Had a friend whose mid-r...

- Good to hear you found someone trustworthy—makes a huge difference. - Had a similar experience a couple years back. Roofer insisted fascia needed fu...

Good points from both sides here. A couple things I'd add from experience: - Metal roof dents can definitely sneak up on you later. Had a few small h...

Yeah, I've noticed the same thing. Passive vents are great most of the time, but in peak summer heat, they can struggle. A neighbor added reflective r...

- Totally agree on the gauge upgrade—did the same thing a few years back, and insurance claims have been way smoother. - One thing though, metal roofs...