You nailed it with the “extra layer of insurance” bit. I’ve seen the same thing—synthetic underlayment just doesn’t break down like old felt, especial...

Yeah, hidden rust is sneaky, especially around the ridge and under old sealant. I’ve pulled off panels that looked fine from the outside, only to find...

That’s pretty much been my experience too—no matter how careful you are with prep and coatings, the salt air finds a way in eventually. I’ve spent mor...

Yeah, Midwest weather is brutal on roofs—hail, ice, all of it. I’ve seen green roof membranes hold up, but only when they’re seriously overbuilt and p...

That “Friday afternoon crew” thing hits home. I’ve seen roofs on brand new houses where the shingles were already curling or the flashing was just sla...

Moss is definitely a fact of life up here, and honestly, I see a lot of folks taking the “wait and see” approach like you. With asphalt shingles, a th...

Couldn’t agree more with that. I’ve seen folks blame the metal when it was really a skipped underlayment or bad fasteners causing issues. I’ll admit, ...

Yeah, that’s definitely a thing. Even with stamped drawings, I’ve run into inspectors who want to see more math or details—especially if it’s a smalle...

Yeah, checking the attic is one of those things people skip, but it really does save headaches later. About the flashing—honestly, I’ve had better luc...

Good points on weatherstripping—it's crazy how much air sneaks through those tiny gaps. Another sneaky spot people overlook is roof flashing, especial...

True, but it really depends on a few factors—roof pitch, age, and materials can make a big difference. Most modern roofs in snowy areas are designed f...