- Totally get where you're coming from. - Tried the mesh guards myself—same deal, just a mat of needles on top. - Foam seemed like a good idea unt...

- Totally agree on how much the base color and lighting mess with your expectations. I painted my front door red last fall and it looked totally diffe...

- I tried the foam ones too and had the same problem—mushy mess after one winter, plus critters loved to mess with them. - Metal screens are what I ...

- I get the hesitation about cutting into a newer roof. Mine’s only 3 years old and I just can’t bring myself to poke holes in it, especially after se...

- Totally get what you mean about the upfront cost—metal was way out of my budget too, especially with everything else new homeowners deal with. - I a...

- Not sure I totally agree about OSB being that much worse. My builder said the new stuff holds up better than it used to, as long as it’s not sitting...