I get where you’re coming from, but I actually went the repair route instead of full replacement after a nasty windstorm. My roof’s about 12 years old, and patching the damaged section cost me under $2,500. Insurance only chipped in a bit, but honestly, not every storm means you need a whole new roof. Sometimes contractors push for total replacement when spot repairs will do, especially if the rest of the roof’s in decent shape. I’d rather save the big spend for when it’s really needed.
- Totally agree, not every storm calls for a full replacement.
- Inspected plenty of roofs after storms—sometimes just a few shingles or flashing need fixing.
-
Sometimes contractors push for total replacement when spot repairs will do
- Seen folks save thousands by patching up, especially on roofs under 15 years old.
- Just make sure no hidden water got in... that's where costs sneak up later.
Just make sure no hidden water got in... that's where costs sneak up later.
That part really hits home for me. After a hailstorm last spring, I thought I'd gotten off easy—just a couple shingles missing on my 8-year-old roof. Had a roofer out and he suggested a full replacement, but it felt like overkill. Ended up getting a second opinion and just patched the damaged spots. Cost me around $600 instead of the $8k they quoted for a new roof.
But yeah, I did have an attic check for leaks and water stains. Turns out, one tiny spot had a drip I would've missed if I hadn't looked. Fixed that with some sealant and a new piece of insulation. If I hadn't caught it, probably would've had mold or a bigger repair down the line.
I get why some folks go for a full replacement, especially if the roof's older or there's a lot of damage. But for newer roofs, spot repairs can save a ton—just gotta be thorough about checking for hidden problems. Storms are stressful enough without getting upsold on stuff you don't need.
That’s a smart move getting a second opinion. I’ve seen way too many folks get talked into full replacements when a targeted repair would do the trick, especially on roofs under 10 years old. Still, I’m always a bit wary—sometimes water finds its way in through spots you’d never expect, and it can take months before you see any real signs. I usually recommend checking the attic after every big storm, not just once. Even a small drip can turn into a headache if it goes unnoticed. Insurance adjusters can be hit or miss too... some catch everything, others breeze through in five minutes.
Curious if you’ve ever had a repair that seemed minor at first but turned into something bigger after a few storms? I always wonder how much of that is just hidden damage versus maybe the materials not holding up as well as promised. Also, do you think insurance usually covers enough, or have you found yourself paying out of pocket more often than not?
