I tried to be super careful cutting in the fan, but even with a shingle bar I still cracked a couple.
That’s just how it goes sometimes, especially when those shingles are baked solid by the sun. Even with all the right tools, you’re gonna lose a few. I always tell folks—keep a tube of sealant handy and don’t stress over a cracked shingle or two. As long as you seal it up right, you’ll be fine. The real trick is not passing out up there... Texas roofs in July are no joke.
Man, I hear you on the Texas heat. I once tried swapping out a couple of ridge vents in August—felt like my boots were melting to the shingles. Did you end up using architectural or three-tab up there? I’ve noticed the thicker ones sometimes crack less, but maybe that’s just luck.
- Texas heat is no joke—pretty sure I lost five pounds just standing on my roof last July.
- I usually go with architectural shingles for jobs like this. They’re a bit heavier, but in my experience, they hold up better when the sun’s trying to cook everything in sight.
- Three-tabs are cheaper, but I’ve seen them curl and crack faster, especially after a hailstorm or two. Maybe it’s just bad luck, but I swear the thicker ones handle the abuse better.
- Had a buddy try to install a solar fan mid-August... he said it felt like grilling himself instead of burgers. Wouldn’t recommend unless you’re part lizard.
I get the love for architectural shingles, but honestly, I went with three-tabs last year just because the price difference was wild. Yeah, they’re not as tough, but if you keep up with repairs and inspections, they can still last a good while. Plus, I’d rather spend less upfront and maybe replace a few here and there than shell out double right away. Not sure if that’s the “right” way, but it worked for my budget.
I totally get where you’re coming from on the three-tabs. I was in the same boat last year—just couldn’t justify the extra cost for architectural, especially with all the other stuff that comes up when you buy your first place. I keep hearing mixed things about how long three-tabs actually last, though. Have you noticed any issues with wind or curling yet? I’m in a spot that gets some pretty gnarly storms, so I’m always a little nervous about shingles flying off.
On the solar attic fan thing—did you have to mess with your shingles much during install? I’ve been thinking about adding one, but I’m worried about messing up the roof and voiding whatever warranty I have left. Did you find it tricky to get everything sealed up again, especially with the thinner three-tabs? I keep reading that architectural shingles are more forgiving if you have to lift them for stuff like this, but maybe that’s just marketing.
Also, did you notice any difference in attic temps after putting in the fan? I’m hoping it’d help with cooling bills, but not sure if it’s worth cutting into a roof that’s still pretty new. Just curious how it went for you—any regrets or things you’d do differently?
