- Totally feel you on the noise issue—had friends who regretted their metal roof choice after just one storm. Said it felt like a drum solo overhead all night...
- Shingles have definitely improved though. We went with impact-resistant shingles a few years back (budget reasons mostly), and honestly they've held up way better than expected.
- One thing I noticed too: shingles seem easier to patch up or replace in sections if there's minor damage. Metal roofs, not so much... repairs can get pricey fast.
- Also, snow sliding off metal roofs can be intense. My neighbor had one, and every winter we'd hear these huge crashes of ice and snow hitting the ground—kinda scary if you're standing nearby.
- Still, metal does have its perks, like longevity. But for cost-effectiveness and ease of maintenance, shingles have been good enough for us so far.
"Also, snow sliding off metal roofs can be intense. My neighbor had one, and every winter we'd hear these huge crashes of ice and snow hitting the ground—kinda scary if you're standing nearby."
Yeah, that's a legit concern. I've seen cases where sliding snow damaged gutters or even landscaping below... not fun to deal with in freezing temps. Curious though, has anyone tried snow guards or retention systems? Heard mixed things about their effectiveness and whether they're worth the extra cost and hassle to install.
"Curious though, has anyone tried snow guards or retention systems? Heard mixed things about their effectiveness and whether they're worth the extra cost and hassle to install."
Installed snow guards on my metal roof about three winters ago. Quick thoughts:
- Definitely reduced those massive snow slides—haven't had any more heart-stopping crashes since.
- Installation wasn't too complicated, but it did take a weekend and some patience (and a buddy to help).
- Cost-wise, not exactly cheap, but cheaper than replacing gutters or fixing landscaping damage every spring.
- One downside: heavy snow tends to pile up more evenly now, so I have to keep an eye on the roof load during big storms. Had to rake it off once or twice when we got slammed with back-to-back blizzards.
Overall, I'd say they're worth it if you're dealing with frequent heavy snowfall. If your winters are milder, might not be necessary.
I put snow guards on my roof last year, and honestly, I'm still kinda on the fence about them. They definitely stopped those scary avalanche-style slides, which is great for peace of mind. But now I notice snow just sits there longer, and I'm wondering if that's gonna cause rust or moisture issues down the line. Haven't had to rake yet, but I'm keeping an eye on it... guess we'll see how it holds up after another winter or two.
Snow guards are a bit of a double-edged sword, aren't they? You're right to wonder about moisture—standing snow can lead to ice dams, especially if your attic insulation or ventilation isn't quite up to snuff. But rust shouldn't be a big concern if your roof is in decent shape. I'd say keep an eye out for icicles or ice buildup near the gutters—that's usually the first sign of trouble. And hey, at least you're not dodging mini avalanches anymore... small victories, right?
