just read about roof issues popping up after winter - are you checking yours?

Wondering if it’s worth the extra cost for a full roof, or just overkill for most homes.

I’ve only put peel-and-stick on valleys and a couple trouble spots, never the whole thing. Honestly, unless you’re dealing with crazy ice dams every winter, I don’t see the point of spending that much more. But maybe I’m missing something - do folks in colder areas really notice a difference, or is it mostly peace of mind?

I’m in a pretty snowy spot and only did full peel-and-stick once, after a nasty ice dam year. Honestly, it wasn’t a game changer - valleys and eaves seem to matter most. Full coverage felt like overkill for my roof, but maybe some folks have worse luck.

I hear you on the full peel-and-stick - it’s marketed as a cure-all, but in my experience, it’s really those trouble spots like valleys, eaves, and any low-pitch sections that need the most attention. I did a full coverage once when I replaced the whole roof, and honestly, aside from a few extra dollars on materials, I didn’t notice much difference in performance compared to just targeting the vulnerable areas. Maybe if you’ve got a really complex roof or some weird microclimate, it’d be worth it, but for most of us, focusing on the weak points seems practical. Guess it’s one of those “belt and suspenders” things some folks swear by...

I get where you’re coming from, but I’ve seen enough storm damage to say full peel-and-stick can be a game changer - especially in places with wild freeze-thaw cycles or wind-driven rain. Sure, it’s overkill for some roofs, but when you’re dealing with ice dams or wind-lifted shingles, that extra layer can mean the difference between a minor repair and a full-blown leak nightmare. I’ve had clients regret skipping it after a rough winter. Still, if your roof’s simple and you’re not in a high-risk area, targeting the valleys and eaves is usually enough. Just depends how much risk you’re willing to take on, I guess.

That’s spot on about peel-and-stick making a difference in rough climates. I’ve inspected roofs after big storms where the only dry spots were under that membrane - especially on older homes with less-than-perfect decking. One thing I’d add: even with good installation, ventilation plays a huge role too. If you’ve got poor airflow in the attic, ice dams can still sneak up on you, no matter how much underlayment you use. It’s all about layering your defenses, literally and figuratively. Sometimes people forget that part and end up with condensation issues instead of leaks... which is just as frustrating.