"Fast forward a year, and I'm up there scraping moss and pulling out random branches after every storm."
Haha, I feel your pain. But honestly, I've had asphalt shingles for years now, and while they're not as pretty as tile, they've been surprisingly low-maintenance for me. Sure, they don't have that classy Mediterranean vibe, but I rarely have to climb up there unless there's a serious storm. Maybe it's just luck or my location... but sometimes the cheaper option ends up being less hassle overall. Just my two cents!
- Tile roofs def aren't maintenance-free, but neither is asphalt.
- Moss buildup depends a lot on shade and moisture levels...maybe your spot's just unlucky?
- Ever considered green roofing? Curious if anyone here's tried it—heard mixed things about upkeep.
Yeah, totally agree—tile roofs aren't exactly set-it-and-forget-it. Seen plenty with cracked tiles after storms or branches falling. Green roofs sound cool, but I've heard they're kinda tricky if drainage isn't spot-on...might be worth researching more first.
Tile roofs definitely aren't maintenance-free, but they're fairly durable if installed correctly. Cracked tiles usually happen from impact or improper foot traffic—seen it plenty myself. The underlayment beneath the tiles is actually critical; if that's compromised, leaks can occur even without visible tile damage. Green roofs are fascinating, though drainage and structural support can be challenging. Curious if anyone's considered composite shingles or metal roofing as lower-maintenance alternatives...they're becoming pretty popular these days.
Had a client once who switched from tile to metal roofing after a nasty hailstorm cracked half his tiles. He was tired of the maintenance headaches—tiles are durable, sure, but they're not bulletproof. Metal roofs have come a long way; they're lighter, easier to maintain, and handle weather pretty well. Composite shingles aren't bad either, though I've seen them curl up after a decade or so. Every roof has its quirks, I guess...
