New Discussion

I’m right there with you on the patch-and-pray method - last summer I used a chunk of old tarp and some duct tape after a branch punched through. Not my proudest DIY moment, but it held up until I could get someone out. About recycled shingles, I checked out Malarkey and GAF’s “Eco” line at Lowe’s, but honestly, the prices were all over the place depending on color and thickness. Didn’t notice much difference in noise, but insulation seemed a bit better than my old asphalt ones. Rebates were tricky - my city had a small one for “cool roof” materials, but nothing major. If you’re already seeing leaks at 15 years, might be worth getting a pro to look before things get worse... learned that the hard way after waiting too long myself.

Patch-and-pray is basically my current strategy too, though I keep wondering if I’m just delaying the inevitable. My place is only 12 years old but I’ve already had to patch a couple spots after a hailstorm last spring. I looked into those recycled shingles as well - Malarkey seemed promising, but the price difference between colors was weirdly high. Did you notice if the lighter colors actually made any difference in attic temps? I read somewhere that “cool roof” materials can drop it by a few degrees, but I’m skeptical unless you’re in direct sun all day.

The rebate thing is confusing. My city’s website lists incentives, but half of them are expired or only apply to commercial buildings. Did you have to submit a bunch of paperwork for yours, or was it automatic with the contractor? Also, did you get any warranty differences with the eco shingles? I’m trying to figure out if the extra cost is worth it long-term or if I should just stick with regular asphalt and budget for more frequent repairs.

I get the temptation to just patch and hope for the best, but honestly, I’m starting to think it’s not always the most cost-effective in the long run. My neighbor went that route for years and ended up with a bigger repair bill after a bad storm last fall. Sometimes it feels like you’re just throwing money at temporary fixes.

About the lighter shingles - my cousin did a full roof replacement with “cool” shingles (not Malarkey, but similar) and said his attic was maybe 4-5 degrees cooler in peak summer. He’s in Texas though, so lots of direct sun. Up here in the Midwest, I’m not convinced it’d make enough difference to justify the price jump, especially if your attic’s already well insulated.

The rebate process was a headache for me. The contractor helped, but I still had to chase down paperwork and wait months for approval. Warranty-wise, the eco shingles had a slightly longer coverage period, but not by much. Personally, I’m leaning toward regular asphalt and just setting aside a bit each year for repairs or eventual replacement. Sometimes simple is better, especially if you’re watching your budget.

I hear you on the patching - my first house, I kept slapping tar on leaks and it just snowballed. Ended up costing more than if I'd bitten the bullet early. As for cool shingles, I’m in Minnesota and honestly didn’t notice much temp difference after switching. Maybe it’s more hype up here than help? The rebate paperwork was a pain for me too... almost not worth the hassle. Regular asphalt’s been fine so far, especially since my attic’s insulated pretty well. Sometimes less fancy really is less headache.

As for cool shingles, I’m in Minnesota and honestly didn’t notice much temp difference after switching. Maybe it’s more hype up here than help?

Yeah, I’ve wondered the same thing. Up here, it feels like insulation does way more for comfort than any fancy shingle tech. I’ve seen folks spend a bunch on those “cool” roofs and still end up with ice dams every winter. Have you ever had issues with ice damming or leaks during the thaw? Sometimes I think the old-school methods work just as well, at least in our climate...