"Did you do insulation at the same time, or just the roof itself? Curious if that combo makes a bigger impact..."
Totally agree with this point—I've managed several properties where we've done roof replacements, and honestly, pairing it with insulation upgrades is usually the way to go. A new roof alone can help with leaks and general maintenance headaches, but if you're looking for noticeable comfort and energy savings, insulation is key. Had one tenant who constantly complained about the upstairs being unbearable in summer; after we redid the roof and added proper attic insulation, they said it was like night and day. Bills dropped a bit too, but the real win was comfort.
On the flip side, I've seen roofs replaced without touching insulation, and while it solved leak issues, tenants didn't really notice much difference in temperature or bills. So yeah, if you're already spending on the roof, might as well tackle insulation at the same time—it's usually worth the extra investment in my experience.
On the flip side, I've seen roofs replaced without touching insulation, and while it solved leak issues, tenants didn't really notice much difference in temperature or bills. So yeah, if you're alr...
Yeah, totally with you on insulation making a difference. I've worked on roofs where we skipped insulation, and honestly, the homeowners didn't notice much beyond fewer leaks. But when we did both together, they were always surprised how much more comfortable the house felt... definitely worth considering.
I remember when my parents redid their roof a few years back. They initially just wanted to fix leaks, but the contractor convinced them to upgrade insulation too. At first, my dad was skeptical—thought it was just upselling—but after the first winter, he admitted the house felt way cozier and their heating bills dropped noticeably. Makes me wonder if insulation might actually be the bigger deal here than the roofing material itself...
"Makes me wonder if insulation might actually be the bigger deal here than the roofing material itself..."
Good point, but I'd say it depends on your situation. When we redid our roof, we went with mid-range shingles instead of premium ones and put the extra money into insulation and sealing drafts. Honestly, zero regrets—house feels warmer, bills are lower, and we didn't overspend on fancy roofing materials. Might be worth considering if you're budget-conscious...
Yeah, insulation definitely plays a bigger role than most people realize. Before you jump into premium shingles, I'd suggest checking your attic first—do you have enough insulation up there? Is it evenly distributed or are there gaps? Also, look into sealing around windows and doors. You'd be surprised how much heat escapes through tiny cracks. Roofing matters, sure, but tackling insulation and drafts first usually gives you more bang for your buck...
