You’re not being paranoid at all. I went the layering route once because it seemed cheaper and less hassle, but a couple years later, we found some soft spots in the decking that nobody caught the first time. Ended up costing more to fix after the fact. Honestly, if you can swing it, tearing off and starting fresh just gives you peace of mind. It’s not fun paying more upfront, but at least you know what you’re dealing with.
Honestly, if you can swing it, tearing off and starting fresh just gives you peace of mind.
I get where you’re coming from, but I’ll admit I went with layering once just because I couldn’t stomach the mess and cost of a full tear-off. Our house is older (built in the 60s), and I figured one more layer wouldn’t hurt. Now I’m wondering if I just kicked the can down the road. Did you notice any difference in how your house handled heat or cold after you did the full tear-off? I’m in the Midwest, so insulation’s a big deal for us.
Now I’m wondering if I just kicked the can down the road.
Honestly, I’ve seen both approaches work out, but I do think tearing off lets you spot any hidden issues (like rotten decking—yikes). On insulation, after a tear-off, we noticed less draftiness in winter, but it could’ve just been sealing up all the weird gaps from the old layers. Midwest winters are no joke, so every little bit helps. Layering’s fine in a pinch, but I’d keep an eye out for ice dams or weird leaks.
I’m right there with you on the confusion. We just bought our place last year and the roof was already pushing 18 years, so I had to make this decision too. I ended up going with a tear-off, partly because I kept hearing horror stories about hidden rot and also because I wanted to make sure the attic insulation was up to par. It’s wild how much air can sneak in through old nail holes and weird gaps—stuff you’d never notice until you’re freezing in January.
I get why people layer, though. The cost savings are real, and if the decking’s solid, it seems fine for a while. But I kept reading about extra weight on the trusses and possible warranty issues if you go that route. Not sure if that’s just contractor talk or legit, but it was enough to make me nervous.
One thing I didn’t expect: after the tear-off, our upstairs was noticeably quieter during rainstorms. Maybe that’s just new shingles plus fresh underlayment, but it was a nice bonus. Midwest weather is brutal, so I figured better safe than sorry... but man, it’s not a cheap call either.
