- Metal’s noise is a dealbreaker for me too, especially during storms. Even with extra insulation, it’s still noticeable.
-
— Yeah, I ran the numbers last year and the “discount” on my policy was almost wiped out by higher deductibles after a hail claim.“sometimes the ‘discount’ barely covers the deductible jump, especially after a big hail year.”
- Impact shingles seem like a solid middle ground. Repairs are easier, and I don’t have to worry about matching faded metal panels down the line.
- Has anyone looked into synthetic slate or tile? I’m curious if the upfront cost is worth it long-term compared to high-end shingles.
- Impact shingles seem like a solid middle ground. Repairs are easier, and I don’t have to worry about matching faded metal panels down the line.
I get the concern about metal noise, but honestly, I think it’s a bit overblown if you go with a good install and solid insulation. That said, I’ve been leaning hard toward green roofs lately—literally a layer of plants and soil on top. They’re not for everyone, but in my area (mild winters, lots of sun), they cut down on heat, last ages, and you never hear rain or hail. Upfront cost is higher than shingles, but I’ve seen the payoff in lower cooling bills and way less storm damage. Maintenance is more like gardening than roofing, though, so it’s not zero effort. Just another angle to consider if you’re already looking at premium options.
Green roofs really are a game changer if you’re up for the maintenance. I put one on my garage a few years back, and honestly, the temp difference inside is wild—barely need AC in summer. Not for everyone, but if you like gardening, it’s kinda fun. Just make sure your structure can handle the weight... that’s the one thing that tripped me up at first.
I’ve been eyeing green roofs too, but honestly, the weight thing freaks me out a bit. My house is old and I’m not sure it’d survive the extra load. If I had to redo my roof tomorrow, I’d probably go metal—less maintenance, lasts forever, and I don’t have to worry about watering anything except my sad lawn. Maybe someday I’ll get brave enough for the garden-on-the-roof thing...
- Gotta admit, metal roofs are tempting—no squirrels digging up your begonias up there.
- But, have you looked into those lightweight green roof systems? Some are surprisingly doable for older houses, especially if you stick to sedum or shallow-rooted stuff.
- I’ve seen a neighbor’s 1920s bungalow rocking a mini meadow—just needed a structural check and some extra support beams.
- Metal’s great for hail and snow, but man, it can sound like a drumline in a rainstorm.
- Personally, I’d go composite shingles. Not as flashy, but they’re lighter than tile or metal, and you don’t need to water anything except your coffee.
- Either way, anything’s better than patching leaks every spring...
