Been thinking lately about roofs (exciting life, I know...) and got into a bit of a debate with my neighbor yesterday. He swears by metal roofing, says it's durable, lasts forever, and all that jazz. But honestly, I can't help but think about the noise factor—rainstorms on metal roofs sound like a marching band practicing overhead, right? Or am I exaggerating?
Then there's asphalt shingles—cheaper upfront, but they don't last as long. And what about those fancy clay tiles? They look amazing, but I'm guessing they're pricey and heavy. I mean, hypothetically, if your roof suddenly vanished overnight (weird scenario, I know), and insurance was footing the bill, would you stick with what you have now or try something totally different?
Curious what others think about this...
I'd probably stick with asphalt shingles, honestly. Sure, they're not forever, but budget-wise they're pretty forgiving. Plus, metal roofs during hailstorms...? Might as well invite a drumline to your attic for a free concert.
I'm with you on asphalt shingles—had them on my last house and they held up pretty well considering the price. Metal roofs do have their perks, though. My neighbor installed one a couple years back, and while it's true that hailstorms sound like a marching band rehearsal, he swears by its durability and energy efficiency. Says his attic stays noticeably cooler in summer, which helps cut down on AC costs.
Still, for me, the noise factor alone is enough to stick with shingles. Plus, repairs are straightforward if you ever lose a few in a storm. Metal roofing repairs seem a bit trickier to DIY, and I prefer something I can handle myself without special tools or skills.
I've managed properties with both metal and asphalt roofs, and honestly, each has its quirks. Metal roofs are great for longevity and energy savings, no doubt about it, but the noise during storms... yeah, that's a real thing. Had tenants call me convinced their roof was about to cave in during a heavy rainstorm—turned out it was just the metal amplifying every drop. Shingles might not last as long, but they're easy enough to patch up yourself without breaking the bank or your back. I'd probably stick with shingles myself, practicality wins for me.
yeah, that's a real thing. Had tenants call me convinced their roof was about to cave in during a heavy rainstorm—turned out it was just the metal amplifying every drop.
Metal roofs aren't always as noisy as people think—depends a lot on insulation and installation quality. But yeah, shingles are definitely easier for DIY repairs. Clay tiles look great but need reinforced framing, so factor that into your budget too.
