I've seen a couple green roofs hold up pretty well around here too, but honestly, metal roofing still seems like the safer bet if heavy storms are your main worry. Green roofs definitely have their perks—insulation, runoff control, aesthetics—but metal's durability and low maintenance after storms is hard to beat. Plus, no worries about plants dying or drainage issues cropping up later...just my two cents from seeing both in action.
Metal roofs definitely have a solid track record when it comes to storm resistance, especially if you're dealing with heavy rain and wind regularly. I've inspected plenty of roofs after storms, and metal consistently holds up better than shingles or green roofs in terms of structural integrity and minimal maintenance afterward. That said, green roofs aren't necessarily a bad choice—they can handle rain surprisingly well if they're properly designed and maintained.
The key issue with green roofs usually isn't the plants themselves (though yeah, dead vegetation can be a hassle), but rather drainage and waterproofing layers underneath. If those aren't installed correctly or maintained over time, you could end up with pooling water or leaks that are tricky to pinpoint. I've seen a few cases where homeowners didn't realize there was an issue until water started seeping through ceilings weeks after a storm—definitely not fun.
Metal roofing, on the other hand, is pretty straightforward. As long as it's installed properly with good flashing and fasteners, it's tough to beat for durability. The main thing to watch out for is hail damage or debris impact during severe storms. Even then, repairs tend to be simpler and quicker compared to shingles or green roofs.
One thing I'd add though: noise can be an issue with metal roofs during heavy rain or hailstorms. Some people find it soothing, others can't stand it...just something to consider depending on your personal preference.
Overall, if storm damage prevention is your top priority, metal roofing is probably your safest bet. But if you're leaning toward green roofs for their environmental benefits or aesthetics, just make sure you invest in quality installation and regular inspections—especially after major weather events.
Good points overall, metal roofs definitely hold up better in storms. One thing I'd add though—metal roofs can be slippery as heck when wet, making post-storm inspections or repairs a bit dicey. Had a close call myself once...not fun. Green roofs are trickier, sure, but if drainage is done right, they're surprisingly resilient. Still, for pure storm protection, metal's probably the safer bet. Just don't underestimate the noise factor—some folks really regret it later.
"Just don't underestimate the noise factor—some folks really regret it later."
Yeah, the noise can definitely catch people off guard. We installed a metal roof about five years ago, and while it's held up great in storms, the first heavy rainstorm was a real eye-opener. Eventually got used to it, but it's something to consider if you're sensitive to noise. As for slipperiness, investing in some roof brackets or safety harnesses makes inspections way safer—worth every penny, trust me.
Haha, yeah, metal roofs and rainstorms...talk about a rude awakening. I remember staying at my cousin's cabin once—middle of nowhere, peaceful as anything—until the rain hit that metal roof at 2 AM. Sounded like someone was dumping buckets of marbles overhead. Took me a good hour to fall back asleep.
But honestly, noise aside, metal roofs seem pretty solid. I've seen shingles fly off in storms more times than I can count, and replacing them gets old fast. At least metal stays put. Curious though, has anyone tried adding insulation or soundproofing underneath? Wondering if that actually helps or if it's just throwing money at the problem...
