Notifications
Clear all

Roof Dramas: Shingles vs. Metal After Heavy Rain

448 Posts
422 Users
0 Reactions
20.4 K Views
susanw74
Posts: 13
(@susanw74)
Active Member
Joined:

Metal roofs definitely have their perks, especially when it comes to maintenance after heavy rains. But have you considered adding gutter guards or screens to your setup? They're pretty affordable and can significantly cut down on the hassle of cleaning out debris after storms. I installed some for a client last summer, and he said it made a noticeable difference in how often he had to climb up there.

"green roofs aren't always smooth sailing either—especially if drainage issues pop up."

Yeah, green roofs can be tricky if the drainage isn't spot-on from the start. Did your friend have a professional install, or was it more of a DIY project? Sometimes, drainage problems come down to the initial slope and layering setup. If done right, they can be pretty low-maintenance, but if not... well, you've seen firsthand how frustrating it can get.


Reply
kathy_meow
Posts: 9
(@kathy_meow)
Active Member
Joined:

I hear you on the green roof drainage headaches... had a buddy who tried a DIY green roof project a couple years back. Looked amazing at first, but after the first big storm, he had mini waterfalls pouring off the sides. Took him ages to sort out the slope and drainage layers properly. Once he got it dialed in though, it was pretty smooth sailing. Hang in there—it can definitely be worth the hassle if you stick with it.


Reply
Posts: 11
(@charliehiker)
Active Member
Joined:

"Looked amazing at first, but after the first big storm, he had mini waterfalls pouring off the sides."

Haha, sounds familiar... Did your buddy end up adding extra drainage channels or just adjusting the slope? I'm currently debating whether to tackle a green roof myself or stick with metal. Seems like every DIY project has that "why did I start this?" moment halfway through. Glad to hear it eventually worked out though—gives me some hope for mine!


Reply
Posts: 9
(@echowoof517)
Active Member
Joined:

Yeah, seen that happen plenty of times. Usually it's slope first—get that angle right, then add drainage channels if needed. Green roofs look great but they're tricky...metal's simpler if you're unsure about maintenance down the line. Just my two cents.


Reply
Posts: 11
(@lstorm23)
Active Member
Joined:

Had a green roof on a shed once—looked awesome at first, but after a couple heavy rains, it turned into a soggy mess. Ended up switching to metal. Less charming, sure, but zero headaches since.


Reply
Page 32 / 90
Share:
Scroll to Top