Yeah, I hear you on the “breathable” gloves—once you’re wrist-deep in sludge, they all feel pretty gross. I’ve tried those reusable ones with the rubber palms, but after a couple washes, they stiffen up or start to smell funky no matter what. The disposables are convenient, especially when you’re dealing with stuff you really don’t want to touch again. I do wonder sometimes if tossing a bunch of them is worse than running the washer more often... but honestly, when they get nasty, I just want them gone.
“but after a couple washes, they stiffen up or start to smell funky no matter what.”
Yeah, that’s the part that gets me. I’ve tried airing them out, even a bit of vinegar, but once that smell sets in… forget it. Disposables might not be great for the planet, but at least my hands don’t reek.
- I hear you on the smell—had a pair of gardening gloves that got so bad, my partner banned them from the mudroom.
- Couple things that helped here: I started tossing them in with a load of towels and using baking soda instead of vinegar. Smell’s not totally gone, but way better.
- Disposables are easy, but I always end up running out mid-project or they tear on me. Plus, the cost adds up over time.
- Not saying reusables are perfect, but with a little extra care (and patience), they can last longer than I expected... just gotta stay on top of cleaning.
I get the appeal of reusables, but honestly, I’ve seen too many folks hang onto gloves or goggles way past their prime just to “save money.” That’s where things can get risky.
Sure, but sometimes that “extra care” slips, especially after a long day. I’ve inspected more than a few garages where old gloves were basically biohazards. Disposables might seem wasteful, but at least you know you’re starting fresh each time—no hidden mold or mystery grime. For certain jobs, I’d rather pay a bit more for peace of mind.“...with a little extra care (and patience), they can last longer than I expected...”
- Totally agree—I've seen folks stash “reusable” gloves in toolboxes for months, and by the time they pull them out, they're stiff or just gross.
- Disposables are easier to track—use once, toss, done.
- For quick jobs or anything messy (paint, plumbing), I’d rather not risk it with old gear.
- That said, I do keep a couple of decent reusables for light stuff, but I’m strict about tossing them when they start to look sketchy.
- Peace of mind’s worth a few extra bucks, especially when you’re responsible for other people’s safety.